Members prior to 1842(record found in other places)

Dennis Carroll, Nancy Carroll, Alexander Redmond, MaryAnn (Mariam) Redmond, Daniel Martin, Celia Martin (colored), John Howel, Jesse Hendrix, Martha Hendrix, E. Pinson (Delegate to Chattahoochee Baptist Association 1834), Charles Harris or Haynes (Delegate to Chattahoochee Baptist Association 1835), Grief Williams (Delegate to Chattahoochee Baptist Association 1835), Chas Haynes or Harris (Delegate to Hightower Baptist Association 1835), and Abraham Beam (Property Deed of 1838)

Oldest Recorded Male Membership List (circa 1842)

Alfred Webb, Johnston Ledbetter, Aaron Kemp (Lettered April 12, 1844; Received by letter May 8, 1845), Bailey F. Julian, John W. Kemp (Lettered 1847), William J. Hudson (Lettered October 1848), Jason McBrayer (Deceased November 12, 1844), Wm. G. Hendricks (Excommunicated March 7, 1846; Restored April 10, 1847), Andrew Jackson Kemp (Excommunicated September 10, 1847), Zechariah Wilkins (Lettered February 12, 1859), Zeno Whitney (Lettered February 11, 1843), Thomas Morgan (Lettered April 12, 1845), James Bramblett (Lettered November 12, 1842), John (Hawkins) Brown (Lettered July 1846), Josiah Thornton (Lettered February 1853), Jacob Carroll (Excommunicated April 11, 1843), James Beaty (Received by letter March 11, 1843; Lettered April 12, 1845), Lemuel Bearden (Received by letter April 11, 1843), Pinkney C. Blanton (Received by letter June 11, 1843), Hiram H. Dean Received by letter April 13, 1844), James Hitte (Received by letter May 1845; Lettered October 11, 1845), A.G. (Thomas) Hendricks (Received by experience July 1845; Excommunicated June 9, 1849), Solomon Taylor (Received by experience July 1845; Lettered 1853), William Barrett (Received by experience October 12, 1845), Nath. B. Banks (Received by letter September 12, 1846; Lettered November 10, 1847), William Fowler (Received by letter May 8, 1847), John Danner (Received by letter November 13, 1847), Hershe Cook (Received by letter January or June 1847), Joshua Robertson (Received by letter January 1849), Christopher Cook (Received by letter January 1849), John J. Blanton (Baptism), John Higgins (Received by letter), John B. Bottoms, John Higgins (By letter), Anonymous Wilkins, Jesse Eskridge, Berry Copeland, Joel T. Heard (Received by letter October 1854), Wm. H. Hendricks (Baptism November 1854), and Philip Cox (Received by letter July 1856)

Oldest Recorded Female Membership List (circa 1842)

Sarah Carroll, Arabella Webb, Dicey Hendricks, Sarah Bird, Vienna Kemp (Lettered April 10, 1847), Nancy Gage (Lettered October 1846), Sarah Gage, Martha Bird, Hannah Morgan (Lettered April 12, 1845), Susannah Hardin, Rebecca (Hawkins) Brown (Lettered July 12, 1846), Lavina Thornton (Lettered February 1853), Frances Gravitte (Dismissed), Nancy Ledbetter, Amelia R. McBrayer, Elizabeth Julian, Mourning Henson, R.E. Julian (Died August 29, 1856), Lucinda Higgins, Amanda Holbrooks (Lettered July 8, 1843), Mariam Redmon, Sarah Kemp (Lettered April 12, 1845), Jane Bramblett (Lettered November 12, 1842), Elizabeth Bramblett (Lettered November 12, 1842), Jemima Cathy (Lettered), Mary Hannon (Received by letter December 11, 1842; Dismissed 1847), Martha Beaty (Received by letter March 11, 1843; Lettered April 12, 1845), Phebe Hamlin (Lettered August 13, 1843), Nancy Shoun (Received by letter December 9, 1843; Lettered), Sarah Dean (Received by letter April 13, 1844; Lettered May 9, 1846), Mariah Gage (Received by letter June 8, 1844; Lettered 1845), Katharine Blanton (Baptism November 9, 1844), Martha Ledbetter (Baptism December 7, 1844), Mary Hitte (Received by letter May 1845; Lettered October 11, 1845), Huldah Hitte (Received by letter May 1845; Lettered October 11, 1845), Jane Hitte (Received by letter May 1845; Lettered October 11, 1845), Nancy Hitte (Received by letter May 1845; Lettered October 11, 1845), Rebecca Hitte (Received by experience or letter July 1845; Lettered October 11, 1845), Sarah Taylor (Received by experience or letter July 11, 1845; Lettered 1853), Martha Barrett (Received by letter October 12, 1845), Jane Banks (Received by letter September 12, 1846; Lettered November 10, 1847), Belariah Wilkins (Received by letter October 1856), Margaret McFarland (Received by letter October 1856), Susanah Logan (Received by letter May 8, 1847; Lettered July 10, 1847), Lucy Fowler (Received by letter May 8, 1847), Emily Logan (Received by letter May 8, 1847), Sarah Kemp (Received by letter May 8, 1847), Mary Echols (Received by letter October 1847), Hannah Echols (Received by letter October 1847), Sharlot Echols (Received by letter October 1847; Lettered), Mary Echols (Received by letter October 1847; Lettered), Matilda E. Robers (Received by experience October 1847), Elisabeth Danner (Received by letter November 1847), Catherine Jurins (Received by experience November 1847), Malinda Bubrss (Received by letter January 1849), Lisen Brooke (Received by letter January 1849), Susannah Wilkins (Baptism), Frances Bottoms (Received by letter March 1850), Vina Whistenhunt (Baptism), Nancy Elliott (Received by letter), Elizabeth Copeland (Received by letter), Sarrah Wilkins (Received by letter; Died May 1854), Rebecca Eskridge, Ellender Milford (Died April 1858), Margaret Barrett (Lettered 1854), Mary Cox (Received by experience June 1856), and Mary Ann Holtzclaw (Received by experience June 1856)

Oldest Recorded Black Male Membership List (circa 1842)

Daniel (Deceased), George (Deceased), Lewis (Property of J. Ledbetter) (Deceased), York (Property of Jacob Carroll) (Lettered July 8, 1843), Jack (Property of Jacob Carroll) (Received by letter November 13, 1842; Lettered July 8, 1843), and Spencer (Property of Harrison Sumerour) (Received by letter April 8, 1849).

Oldest Recorded Black Female Membership List (circa 1842)

Seliah (Lettered January 1844; Received by letter June 1856), Choicy, Ursula, Malinda (Property of A.H. Hutsons) (Lettered September 9, 1843), Rosannah (Property of Samuel Julian) (Excluded June 10, 1843), Amy (Received by letter December 1844), Blackbine Tilda (Received by experience November 10, 1847; Lettered 1848), Kiley Many (Received by experience November 10, 1848; Lettered), Siller (Received by letter April 8, 1849), Elizabeth (Servant of Rachael Foster) (Received by letter or certificate September 1850), Lucretia (Received by letter 1851), and Dilany (Received by letter 1851)

March 1859 List of Male Members

Alfred Webb, Johnston Ledbetter, Aaron Kemp, Bailey F. Julian (Lettered May 11, 1861), Wm. G. Hendricks, Pinkney Blanton (Received by letter June 11, 1843), Wm. A. Barrett (Received by experience October 11, 1845), Joshua Robertson (Received by letter December 1848 or June 1849; Excluded September 1850), Christopher Cook (Received by letter December 1848 or June 1849; Lettered October 1858), John J. (or L.) Blanton (Received by experience July 1849), John Higgins (Received by letter September 1849), John B. Bottoms (Received by letter March 1850), Jessie E. Eskridge (Received by experience September or October 1851; Excluded April 1862), A. H. (or W.) Wilkins (Received by experience October 1853; Lettered February 8, 1861), Jacob Hays (Received by letter February 1854; Lettered February 1860), Robert Hays (Received by letter February 1854; Lettered February 1860), Berry C. Copeland (Received by letter May 1854), Joel T. Heard (Received by letter October 1854), Wm. H. Hendricks (Received by experience November 1854), Phillip Cox (Received by letter July 1856), Enoch Bramblett or Higgins (Received by experience September 1856), A.J. Sutton (Received by experience October 1856), John W. Wilkins (Received by experience October 1856), William W. Harris (Received by experience October 1856), Wm. A. McBrayer (Received by experience October 1857), James Milford (Received by experience October 1858), Absalom Howard (Received by letter September 1859), Lee R. Hendricks (Received by letter September 1859), Samuel McBrayer (Received by experience October 1859), Milton Compton (Received by letter September 1860), Michael Hollenshed (Received by baptism October 1861), James Anderson Hope (Received by letter November 8, 1862), and Wm. Phillip (Received by letter January 11, 1863)

March 1859 List of Female Members

Arabella Webb, Dicey M. Hendricks, Sarah Bird, Martha Bird, Susannah Hardin, Nancy Ledbetter, Amalia R. Blanton (Died June 9, 1861), Elizabeth Julian (Lettered January 12, 1862), Elizabeth Henson, Lucindia Higgins, Catherine Blanton (Received by experience November 1844), Martha Ledbetter (Received by experience December 1844; Lettered May 11, 1861), Sarah Kemp (Received by letter May 1847), Malinda E. Roberts (Received by experience October 1847; Lettered June 10, 1860), Susanah Wilkins (Received by letter 1849), Frances Bottoms (Received by letter March 1850), Nancy Phillips (Received by letter November 1850), Rebecca Eskridge (Received by letter July 1851; Died), Sarah A. Blanton (Received by experience October 1851), Martha A. Bulls (Received by letter), Elizabeth Porter (Received by letter September 1853), Malinda Hays (Received by letter February 1854; Lettered February 1860), Nancy Elliot (Received by letter May 1854), Elizabeth Copeland (Received by letter May 1854), Mary Cox (Received by experience June 1856), Mary A. Holtzclaw (Received by experience June 1856), Sarah A. Sutton (Received by experience October 1856), Lucretia Wilkins (Received by experience October 1856), Jane Bruton (Received by letter June 1857), M.A. Harris (Received by experience October 1857), Mary McClure (Received by experience), S.A. Harris (Received by experience March 1857), Vina or Viny Whistenhunt (Received by letter November 1852), Mary Howard (Received by letter September 1859), Mary Vaughn (Received by letter September 1859), Rebecca J. Hendricks (Received by letter September 1859), Sephrona Compton (Received by letter September 1860), Martha Barrett, Lavenia McBrayer (Received by experience October 1859), Nancy Blanton (Received by experience November 1859), Mary M. Redmon (Received by letter June 1860), Mary Ann Jane Cox (Received by experience December 1860), Harriet Redmon (Received by letter June 7, 1862), Francis M. Harris (Received by letter September 14, 1862), Georgia Ann Harris (Received by letter September 14, 1862), Hannah Hope (Received by letter November 8, 1862), and Sarah A. Hope (Received by letter November 8, 1862).

March 1859 List of Black Male Members

None listed
 
 

March 1859 List of Black Female Members

Delaney (Received by letter April 1851), Celia (Received by letter June 1856), Choicy, Ursula

1873 List of Male Members

Alfred Webb, Pinkney Blanton, Wm. A. Barrett, John Higgins, John B. Bottoms, Joel T. Heard, Phillip Cox, William W. Harris, Wm. A. McBrayer, James Milford, James Anderson Hope, Claiborne Harris, Alberry Bruton, Andrew Jackson Kemp, B.F. Pruitt, Elijar Holtzclaw, Wm. Humphery, Marion L. Cox, Wm. M. Jones, J.M. Whitmire, J.M. Redmon, and Doctor L. Holtzclaw

1873 List of Female Members

Arabella Webb, Susanah Hardin, Mary Ann Redmon, Martha Bird, Elizabeth Henson, Catherine Blanton, Martha Barrett, Susanah Redmon, Francis Bottoms, Sarah A. Blanton, Elizabeth Porter, Mary Cox, Mary A. Holtzclaw, Jane Bruton, Sally A. Milford, Martha A. Harris, Mary Ann Jane Cox, Nancy Evans, Harriett Redmon, Francis Harris, Georgiann Cox, Hanah Hope, Sarah A. Hope, Emly Cox, Jane (Jamie) Wood, Elmina Bruton, Elizabeth Wood, Nancy A. Barrett, Mary Ann Hill, Martha J. Hill, S.U. Hyde, Martha Cox, Mary Crow, Jane Jones, H.F. Whitmire, and M.E, Whitmire

List of Male Members (circa 1894)

H.L. Pruitt, Albert Webb Pruitt, Monroe D. Harris, Claiborn Harris, Chas. D. Heard, John Joab Bruton, E.S. Roach, Silas Pruitt, W.W. Heard, Lee Croy, Sam Staton, Aaron Sewell, Benj Qualls, Benj Howard, Isaac Howard, Fred H. Pruitt, James M. Howell, Wm. A. Pruitt, Luther Wallace, John Reid, James M. Howell, David A. Cornett, J.H. Satterfield, Rester Groover, and ___ (Rester) McBrayer

List of Female Members (circa 1894)

Martha Barrett, Leola Bruton, Harriett Redmon, Faith Melissa Kemp, S.A. Hope, Hester Ann Isabel Kemp, N.A. Barrett, Martha A. Whitmire, Martha Hill, M.E. Hope, Sally Harris, M.V. Pruitt, Annah Harris, Elizabeth Barrett, Cora Harris, Frances L. Heard, Rosalio Harris, Mary Harris, Nancy Bruton, Margarett Howard, Sallie Wood, Martha E. Howard, Lissa Moore, S. Collett, Mary (Many) Nelson, Nancy E. Collins, Martha McDugal, Eller Hulsey (NE Thrashin), Newell Pruett, Nancy Gasaway, N.A. Williams, Arabella Groover, Cynthia A. Heard, Mary Scott, Sarah Redmon, Nancy Scott, Nancy Ashworth, Parthena Scott, M.I Wallis, M. Roach, M.R. Nelson, M.E. Bruton, Mabel Redmon, Rixey Wood, Mary A. Harris, Martha P. Heard, Minnie Harris, Ethel Heard, Hannah Pruitt, Lizzie Hagood, Louiza Howell, Pauline Heard, Flora Bruton, Bessie Harris, Minnie Clark, Callie Hawkins, Louiza Howell, Viney Cornett, Mary Monroe, Elizabeth Monroe, and Mrs. J.H. Satterfield

Alphabetized list of members not recorded on the 1800s membership lists

Sis. Adam, N.L. Adams, Mrs. N.L. Adams, James Ashworth, Mrs. (Nancy) James Ashworth, John A. Banister, J.H. Barrett, W.A. Barrett, Samuel Beasden, Ely Blanton, Ann Bradley, Mrs. James Bramblett, Elizer Brooks, Martha B. Bruton, Jess Collett, William Collett, Eliza Couh, James Cox, John Cox, Nancy S. Cox, R.H. Cox, Sarah Cox, Susanah Cox, George Dooly, Jane Foster, Lucinda Fowler, Nancy Grun, Nathaniel Hall, Corig Harris, Elia S. Harris, J.J. Harris, Sis. M.E. Harris, Nancy A. Harris, Rosalee Harris, Samuel Harris, W.A. Harris, Emly Harrison, Jesse T. Harrison, Emmer Heard, Geo. L. Heard, G.W. Heard, James L. Heard, Jr., J.L. Heard, Mrs. J.L. Heard, John Heard, Lavada Heard, Seamore Heard, Seamour Heard, Sill Hide, Martha Hight, Cyrus Hill, Elliy Hill, Mary Jane Hill, R. Hill, Rheubin Hill, Elias Holtzclaw, Elvina Holtzclaw, Martha Hope, Mary Jane Hope, Nancy E. Hope, N.E. Hope, T.L. Hope, William J. Hope, A. Howard, David Humphrey, Mary Jones, Br. Jordan & wife, May Lily, Glen Martin, Nilig Martin, R. Martin & sister, Sealy Martin, B. McBrayer, Margret McFarland, A.J. Milford, David J. Milford, Pinkey Milford, Sarah A. Milford, Lisa Mone, Amy Monroe, Gusta Monroe, Verny Monroe, J.C. Nelson, John C. Nelson, Buman Perry, Ferud People, A.H. Pruitt, H.M. Pruitt, John Pruitt, John W. Pruitt, Mary Pruitt, Nuad Pruitt, Mrs. Benj Quarles, Sis. Genie Quarles, Ellen Redd, Bascomb Redmon, Geo. Redmon, Henny Redman, James Redman, Mabelle Redmon, Oliver Redmon, Annie Richards, Wm. H. Richards, Rose (Negro woman of Samuel Julian), John Scott, Aaron Sewell, J. Sewell, Saphia Shelton, Cynthia A. Sherrill, Eli S. Sherrill, Marium Shumaker, Elizabeth Slaggs, Alexander C. Sloan, Cloah Smallwood, June Smallwood, Susannah Smallwood, Elizabeth Smith, J.E. Smith, Mrs. J.E. Smith, W.P. Smith, R.P. Staton, Martha E. Summerour, Adaline Sutton, Adder Tallison, Othelo Tallison, L. Taylor, Mrs. L. Taylor, A. Tenion, Elizabeth Thomas, Jay Thomas, Many Thomas, Br. Veal, Billy Wallis, C. Wallis, James Warren Wallis, S.A. Wallis, Sarah E. Wallis, W.D. Wallis, Wm. Wallis, Clara West, George West, Monroe West, Vergina West, A.O. Whitmire, Dora Whitmire, Effie Whitmire, H.A. Whitmire, S.M. Whitmire & Family, Virginia H. Wilken, Charlie Wilkie, Ed Wilkie, Emmer Wilkie, Sis. M.E. Wilkie, America Wilkins, F.M. Williams, Martha Williams, Henry Wood, Henry J. Wood, James Wood, M.V. Wood, Almeda Wyatt, and Rich Yader