| Name | Born | Died | Age | Additional Inscriptions/Information |
| ASHLOCK, John H. | 10 Mar 1838 | 7y 9m | ||
| HARDCASTLE, George A. | 15 ??? 1851 | Son of Edward & Eliza Hardcastle | ||
| HARDCASTLE, James | 15 Aug 1852 | 21y 3m 18d | (Stone moved to Carrollton City Cem.) | |
| HARDCASTLE, John | 27 Jan 1793 | 16 Sep 1873 | 80y 7m 19d | (Stone moved to Carrollton City Cem.) |
| HARDCASTLE, Margaret H. | 8 Dec 1806 | 27 Mar 1882 | 75y 3m 24d | Wife of John (Stone moved to Carrollton City Cem.) |
| HARDCASTLE, Matilda | 12 Aug 1845 | 4y 7m | Dau of J. & M.W. (Stone moved to Carrollton City Cem) | |
| HARDCASTLE, Thomas | 21 Aug 1854 | 17y 1m 12d | Son of J. & M.W. (Stone moved to Carrollton Cem.) | |
| HUDSON, Mary E. | 12 Jul 1865 | 2y 9m 11d | Dau of W.H. & Lavinia Hudson | |
| JAMES, Charles F. | 4 Jul 1834 | 15 Jun 1912 | ||
| JAMES, Emily | 26 Jan 1870 | 34y 8m | Wife of Charles F. James | |
| JAMES, Harry T. | 27 Aug 1866 | 4 Jan 1882 | Son of Charles & Emily James | |
| JAMES, Winfield | 20 Jan 1858 | 1y 6m 8d | Son of C.F. & E. James | |
| KERBY, Caleb | 18 Aug ???? | Son of Daniel & Polly Kerby | ||
| KERBY, Joshua C. | 3 May 1858 | 31y 1m 27d | Son of D. & E. Kerby | |
| KIRBY, Daniel | 9 Aug 1851 | Son of D. & E. Kirby | ||
| KIRBY, Eliza (Hardcastle) | 26 Feb 1831 | 33y 4m 17d | ||
| KIRBY, Mary | 18 Aug 1856 | 59y 2m 23d | Wife of Daniel | |
| MCPHERRON, Lorenzo D. | 5 Oct 1833 | 1m 29d | Son of A. & H. McPherron | |
| MCPHERRON, Lucinda J. | 19 Jan 1832 | 1y 8m 4d | Dau of A. & H. McPherron | |
| MORRIS, Mary | 31 Mar 1842 | 30y 3d | Wife of Lorenzo D. Morris | |
| MORRIS, Nancy | 31 May 1850 | 62y 3m 23d | Wife of William Morris | |
| MORRIS, William | 6 Aug 1833 | 65y 11m 16d | ||
| RUSSELL, Lucy (Hardcastle) | 1843 | 1898 | Wife of J.M. Russell | |
| SINCLAIR, Infant | 6 Nov 1864 | Dau of J.P. & M. | ||
| STANDEFER, Samuel | 13 Mar 1777 | 13 Jun 1840 | 63y 3m |