| Name | Born | Died | Age | Additional Inscription/Info. |
| BAILEY, Abraham R. | 4 Mar 1789 | 15 Jan 1877 | 87y10m11d | (Born Springfield, Essex Co., NJ) (See 1872 bio) |
| BAILEY, Elizabeth | 12 Dec 1803 | 1 Oct 1884 | 80y9m19d | Wife of A.R. Bailey |
| HEFFNER, Joseph F. | 1833 | 1919 | (Best known as Francis Heffner) | |
| HEFFNER, Phoebe E. | (9 Aug) 1842 | (3 Aug) 1930 | Wife of Joseph F. Heffner; Dau of Abraham R. and | |
| Elizabeth Sullins Bailey. Born in Missouri. | ||||
| HEFFNER, Merrus A. | (25 Jul 1867) | 6 Aug 1961 | 94y11d | (Never married; son of J.F. & P.E. Heffner) |
| Considered an eccentric person by some of his | ||||
| neighbors, he enjoyed making drawings and carving | ||||
| wood. His grave is the northernmost burial in the | ||||
| cemetery marked only with a funeral home marker. | ||||
| HEFFNER, Phebe Inez | 30 Jul 1870 | 28 Dec 1958 | (Phebe was born in Morgan County, daughter of | |
| Joseph F. & Phoebe Heffner. She never married. | ||||
| She seldom visited with neighbors and didn't | ||||
| encourage visitors. She is known to have worn men's | ||||
| shoes which she laced with baling wire. She was a | ||||
| crack shot with a rifle and is known to have regularly | ||||
| gone out with a rifle and bagged some wild game | ||||
| which she would then cook for the evening meal for | ||||
| her brother Merrus and herself. An often told story | ||||
| is that upon her death, brother Merrus was seen | ||||
| dragging her coffin up the bluff to the cemetery, and | ||||
| that neighbors then assisted him in completing the | ||||
| task. The story is branded as a fairy tale by | ||||
| Melvin Dufelmeier, who himself was a pallbearer at | ||||
| Phoebe's funeral. Mr. Dufelmeier knows that Phoebe's | ||||
| grave is immediately south of the grave of Merrus | ||||
| Heffner. Her grave is marked only with on unreadable | ||||
| funeral home marker. | ||||
| HEFFNER, William F. | 16 Nov 1860 | 1m28d | Son of J.F. & P.E. Heffner | |
| (His name is carved on the same obelisk as that of | ||||
| his grandparents, Abraham R. & Elizabeth Bailey. | ||||