| Marriage Date | Groom Name | Age | Where From | Bride Name | Age | Where From | Comments/Witnesses |
| 27 Mar 1915 | Anders, William T. | 19 | Davidson, Effie F. | 18 | Springfield, IL | ||
| 22 Feb 1885 | Antle, James S. | Salisbury, IL | Peterson, Effie M. | Island Grove | married at the parsonage | ||
| 29 Jul 1890 | Beaney (?), Benjamin | Beaney (?), Jane | married at the home of the bride | ||||
| 22 Dec 1887 | Beck, Alexander | Island Grove | Lochsinger, Eliza Olive | Island Grove | married at home of Mrs. Joseph Reing (?) and Kin. | ||
| 15 Jan 1914 | Black, Herman O. | 22 | New Berlin, IL | Chilton, Wilhelmina Jane | 20 | New Berlin, IL | married at the home of the bride |
| 21 Aug 1883 | Bottoms, W. Rufus | Jacksonville, IL | Seymour, Luella | Jacksonville, IL | married at her grandfathers, Witnesses: W. S. Phillips & Wm. Anderson | ||
| 19 Mar 1895 | Brandenburg, Otto | New Berlin, IL | Mantle, Alice | New Berlin, IL | married at Island Grove church | ||
| 30 Oct 1901 | Brown, John I. | 24 | Pleasant Plains, IL | Gregory, Sallie L. | 22 | New Berlin, IL | married at Island Grove parsonage |
| 24 June 1875 | Burg, John | Dalton City, IL | Douglas, Caroline | Spring Creek | |||
| 30 Sep 1914 | Burns, Lee W. | 22 | Buffalo Hart, IL | Wilcox, Mollie R. | 21 | Modesto, IL | |
| 4 Oct 1866 | Camm, Col. William | Winchester, IL | McLeod, Virginia | Sangamon Co., IL | |||
| 1899 | Carter, James | New Berlin, IL | Mantle, Martha | New Berlin, IL | married at brides home | ||
| 10 Oct 1867 | Cheever, Ammi C. | Omaha, NE | Craig, Mary M. | Sangamon Co., IL | |||
| 5 Sep 1900 | Chilton, Joseph | Huffmaster, Katie | New Berlin, IL | married at brides home | |||
| 22 Oct 1868 | Chrisman, Stanford H. | Waverly, IL | Dunlap, Elizabeth | Island Grove | Witnesses: Thos. Keplinger, C. Hedges, Fannie Harris & friends. | ||
| 12 Jan 1899 | Cochler, Fred | 27 | New Berlin, IL | Farley, Katherine | 23 | Island Grove | married at parsonage |
| 29 Nov 1870 | Curts, George | Morgan Co., IL | Parker, Ann C. | Sangamon Co., IL | Witnesses: Jane C. Clark, Minnie Barton & Lou Parker | ||
| 21 Dec 1898 | Darley, Samuel | Pisgah, IL | Cress/Cross, Sadie | Pisgah, IL | married at Jacksonville, IL | ||
| 13 Sep 1910 | Davenport, Benjamin | 22 | Wackerly, Mamie | 20 | married at the parsonage | ||
| 20 Jul 1899 | Davis, Edward | New Berlin, IL | ???, Martha | New Berlin, IL | married at Baptist church at New Berlin | ||
| 4 Nov 1869 | Dyke, Aaron | Island Grove | Dyke ??, Cordelia | Island Grove | Witnesses: John & M. Davis, Ben Sebring & Wesley Se(?). | ||
| 25 Jan 1865 | Elliott, Thomas | 23 | Dawson, Sarah Adaline | 19 | Mother objected to marriage, but was over-ruled | ||
| 10 Sep 1868 | Fehanour?, Charles | Little York, IL | Coons, Martha L. | ||||
| 5 May 1870 | Gallagher, James | Island Grove | Farley, Nancy | Island Grove | Witnesses: Jacob Knows, John Corely, Rebecca Farley & Steve Ray | ||
| 14 Aug 1914 | Griffith, Leland S. | 27 | Caldwell, Jane M. | 22 | Alexander, IL | married at the Alexander church | |
| 6 Feb 1866 | Harris, George S. | Decatur, IL | Jackson, Eliza J. | Sangamon Co., IL | |||
| 11 Jan 1866 | Hedges, Caleb | Dunlap, Terrese | Married at Bride's home in New Berlin | ||||
| 25 Jan 1866 | Hersman, Joseph H. | Versailles, IL | Buckingham, Harriet A. | Jacksonville, IL | |||
| 29 Oct 1913 | Hess, Edward C. | 23 | New Berlin, IL | Reichart, Mable L. | 20 | Pleasant Plains, IL | married at brides home |
| 26 Feb 1874 | Johnson, William | Island Grove | Luchsinger, Maria | Salisbury, IL | Witnesses: Mrs. Johnson & friends | ||
| 1 Apr 1885 | Keeny/Kenny, Joseph A. | Island Grove | Lachsinger, Jeanette | Island Grove | married at the parsonage | ||
| 24 Sep 1874 | Kelly, James L. | Georgetown, KY | Smith, Ruth W. | Island Grove | |||
| 9 May 1869 | Keplinger, Thomas | Sangamon Co., IL | Harris, Fannie | Sangamon Co., IL | Witnesses: Frank & Rachel Keplinger, & relatives of the bride. | ||
| 11 Apr 1883 | Kessler, John | Island Grove | Shuff, Elizabeth A. | Island Grove | She a widow - married at her home. | ||
| 26 Mar 1893 | Lummis, James P. | Paloma, IL | Zinn, Ida May | Island Grove | married at parsonage | ||
| 14 Dec 1870 | Lyman, William | Island Grove | Hawkins, Mary | Island Grove | Witnesses: John Hawkins & Flora Barton | ||
| 30 Jan 1913 | Mantle, Harry J. | 23 | Keiger, Ruth F. | 22 | Alexander, IL | married at brides home | |
| 1900 | McClain, Mr. | New Berlin, IL | Sevier, Jennie | New Berlin, IL | married at brides home | ||
| 15 Mar 1913 | Melton, William D. | 31 | Ruble, Clara Alice | 22 | New Berlin, IL | married at the church | |
| 6 Dec 1894 | Montgomery, Harvey E. | Weldon, IL | Stubbs, Ruth L. | New Berlin, IL | married at brides home | ||
| 10 Sep 1871 | Morehouse, Doran | Morgan Co., IL | Williams, Elizabeth M. | Island Grove | Witnesses: Rev. P. Slagle, Lou Parkers, W.B. Smith & A.C. Barton | ||
| 30 Aug 1911 | Morgan, John W. | 32 | Moats, Elizabeth M. | 25 | Alexander, IL | married at parsonage | |
| 15 May 1873 | Price, William B. | Berlin, IL | O'Bannon, Eliza C. | Island Grove | Witnesses: John & Anna Smith | ||
| 11 Jan 1899 | Prince, Abner | 31 | New Berlin, IL | Turpin, Olive | 20 | New Berlin, IL | married at parsonage |
| 24 Dec 1893 | Reisbeiter, Henry | Ashland, IL | Anders, Bertha | Berlin, IL | married at the residence of the bride | ||
| 4 Jun 1913 | Ruble, Clarence | 22 | Gornis ?, Mary L. | 18 | New Berlin, IL | married at brides home | |
| 12 Feb 1884 | Scott, John | Island Grove | Wilcox, Charlotte | Island Grove | Witnesses: Benjamin Wilcox, a brother of the bride & Mrs. Scott | ||
| 25 Mar 1915 | Scott, John | 60 | Chilton, Bessie P. | 40 | New Berlin, IL | ||
| 24 Dec 1874 | Shuff, William H. | Island Grove | Blaney, Hattie E. | Island Grove | |||
| 22 Mar 1916 | Smith, Quincy | 21 | Cummings, Blanch | 18 | New Berlin, IL | ||
| 6 Nov 1872 | Stubbs, William | Spring Creek | Johnson, Anna A. | Island Grove | Witnesses: Nellie Henry & friend | ||
| 23 Feb 1871 | Sweet, Albert | Loami, IL | Brown, Mary | Island Grove | Witnesses: Kate Barton, Minnie Barton & Alva Baston/Boston | ||
| 26 Sep 1914 | Wackarla, George M. | 21 | Alexander, IL | Dunlap, Josie M. | 21 | Alexander, IL | |
| 29 Oct 1899 | Wilcox, Clarence B. | 32 | New Berlin, IL | Harris, Lucy | 25 | Modesto, IL | |
| 10 Feb 1914 | Wilcox, Holland W. | 23 | New Berlin, IL | Dunlap, Grace Laird | 23 | New Berlin, IL | married at the home of the bride |
| 7 Aug 1866 | Wilcox, John T. | Island Grove | Scott, Sarah F. | Waverly, IL | |||
| Nov 1893 | Wilcox, Warren | New Berlin, IL | McMillan, Kittie | Berlin, IL | married at home of the bride | ||
| 23 Sep 1914 | Wilson, Thomas T. | 21 | New Berlin, IL | Wilcox, Litha B. | 21 | New Berlin, IL | married at the home of the bride |