| Name | Date of Full | Other Additional Information |
| Connection | ||
| to the Church | ||
| Sandidge, Abigail | married Mr. Mantle | |
| Sandidge, Richard (Mrs) | 12 May 1907 | Deceased |
| Sebring, Benjamin | removed to Old Berlin | |
| Sebring, Charles | 23 Aug 1884 | removed |
| Seddin, Alfred | removed 1866 | |
| Seddin, Elizabeth | ||
| Seifert, John | 1 Jun 1890 | removed |
| Seifert, Lina | 1 Jun 1890 | removed |
| Sevier, Ida | 6 Jan 1895 | married Frank Graham |
| Sevier, Johnny | 6 Jan 1895 | removed |
| Sevier, William | 6 Jan 1895 | removed |
| Sevier, William (Mrs) | 6 Jan 1895 | removed |
| Sexton, Alice | 4 Aug 1895 | removed |
| Sexton, Mary | 1 Jun 1890 | Died 15 Jan 1893 |
| Sexton, Ruth Lee | 1 Jun 1890 | Married Harvey Montgomery |
| Seymour, Hattie M. | Sep 1881 | pastor's daughter |
| Seymour, Julia C. | Sep 1881 | pastor's wife |
| Shafer, James | 13 Sep 1868 | removed 1870 |
| Shafer/Saffer, Charles S. | 27 Jul 1902 | removed |
| Shafer/Saffer, Edna | 27 Jul 1902 | removed |
| Shafer/Saffer, Walter | 10 May 1908 | |
| Sharp, Callie | 4 Aug 1895 | removed |
| Sharp, Florence | 27 Jan 1895 | removed |
| Sharp, Jennie | 22 Jun 1890 | removed |
| Sharp, Lucy | 6 Jan 1895 | removed |
| Sharp, Lydia Ann | 31 Aug 1884 | removed |
| Sharp, Marcus James | 1 Jun 1890 | removed |
| Sharp, Sarah E. | 13 Sep 1891 | Died 16 Apr 1900 |
| Sharp, William | 1 Jun 1890 | Died 19 Jan 1898 |
| Sheep, Mary Johnson | 1 Sep 1890 | Died 26 Mar 1897 |
| Shepard, Abbie | 22 Aug 1910 | |
| Shepard, James | 12 May 1907 | |
| Shepard, Mary | 22 Aug 1910 | |
| Shepard, Susie | 22 Aug 1910 | |
| Shoyer, Leah | 14 Sep 1873 | removed 1879 |
| Shryer ?, Ephriam | 31 Dec 1865 | removed 1870 |
| Shryer ?, Mary Ann | 31 Dec 1865 | removed 1870 |
| Shue, D. M. | removed 1870 | |
| Shue, Edward | 13 Sep 1868 | removed 1870 |
| Shue, James | 20 Aug 1865 | removed 1870 |
| Shue, Joseph | 13 Sep 1868 | removed 1870 |
| Shue, M. E. | removed 1870 | |
| Shue, R. G. | removed 1870 | |
| Shue, Robert | 20 Aug 1865 | removed 1870 |
| Simpson, George W. | 22 Aug 1910 | |
| Simpson, J. W. | 16 Mar 1875 | |
| Simpson, Mary | 16 Mar 1875 | |
| Simpson, Millie | Jun 1894 | |
| Skeen, Lydia | removed to Old Berlin | |
| Skeen, Reubin | ||
| Smith, Ann P. | 1 Feb 1873 | Died |
| Smith, Annie | 6 Jan 1895 | removed November 1891 |
| Smith, Bessie B. | removed | |
| Smith, Betty | 23 Jul 1922 | removed |
| Smith, Elisha | 19 Jun 1887 | Died July 1889 |
| Smith, Hattie | 6 Jan 1895 | removed |
| Smith, Hattie Dewes | 25 Aug 1889 | baptized this date |
| Smith, J. D. | Died 7 Nov 1871 - killed by horses | |
| Smith, James D. Jr. | ||
| Smith, James Douglas | 25 Aug 1889 | baptized this date |
| Smith, Jennie | removed | |
| Smith, John T. | removed | |
| Smith, Julia K. | Aug 1876 | removed March 20, 1895 |
| Smith, Julia K. | 11 Sep 1908 | |
| Smith, Lida | 31 Aug 1884 | married D. Henry |
| Smith, Lizzie | 6 Jan 1895 | |
| Smith, Lloyd | 15 Sep 1868 | removed 1896 |
| Smith, Louise | 6 Jan 1895 | removed |
| Smith, Mary | 19 Jun 1887 | Died |
| Smith, Noah | ||
| Smith, Patty D. | 15 Sep 1868 | removed 1872 |
| Smith, Ruth | 31 Aug 1884 | married E. W. Brown |
| Smith, Ruth | 23 Jul 1922 | removed |
| Smith, Ruth Ann | Died 7 Sep 1872 | |
| Smith, Ruth W. | 6 Jun 1869 | married Kelly - removed Jan. 8, 1875 |
| Smith, Sue | ||
| Smith, William B. | removed 20 Mar 1895 | |
| Snyder, L. | ||
| Stockton, Bailey | 1891 | removed |
| Stockton, Chester | 15 Aug 1915 | removed |
| Stroisch, Joe | 2 Feb 1919 | removed |
| Stubbs, Alice May | 1 Jun 1890 | removed Feb. 10, 1896 |
| Stubbs, Anna A. | 31 Aug 1884 | removed Feb. 10, 1896 |
| Stubbs, Eddy | 23 Aug 1885 | removed 4 Sep 1895 |
| Stubbs, William | 31 Aug 1884 | removed |
| Sullivan, Lewis Henry | 21 May 1916 | removed |
| Sweet, Sarah | 1 Jan 1890 | removed |
| Tash, Amanda | 10 Sep 1868 | removed |
| Taylor, Frank | 6 Sep 1868 | removed 8 Sep 1868 ? |
| Thornton, Maude (Mrs) | 12 May 1907 | |
| Tinsley, George Carson | 6 Jan 1895 | |
| Tompkins, John | 5 Feb 1888 | removed |
| Tompkins, Justinia | 5 Feb 1888 | removed |
| Tunnel, Elizabeth | 7 Apr 1874 | removed |
| Tunnel, Wesley | 7 Apr 1874 | removed |
| Ulmer, Charles H. | 15 Jun 1884 | removed 6 Sep 1885 |
| Ulmer, Lewis | 15 Jun 1884 | removed 6 Sep 1885 |
| Ulmer, Susan | 15 Jun 1884 | removed 6 Sep 1885 |
| Wagoner, George | removed 1866 | |
| Walters, Eva | 12 May 1907 | |
| Walters, Frank (Mrs) | 6 May 1923 | |
| Walters, Jessie | Jun 1909 | |
| Walters, Mrs. | 6 Sep 1885 | Died 7 Feb 1910 |
| Walters, Opal | 23 Jul 1922 | |
| Walters, Rachel | 6 Jan 1895 | |
| Walters, Sue | 6 Sep 1885 | See Farley |
| Ward, Sarah | Died April 1866 | |
| Warren, Lois (Mrs) | Oct 1873 | |
| Watkins, J. A. | removed to Old Berlin | |
| Watkins, R. C. (Mrs) | removed to Old Berlin | |
| Watret, John | Jun 1874 | |
| Weiger, John | Died 1867 | |
| Weiger, Nancy | ||
| Westfall, Elizabeth | ||
| Whitehead, Clemmie M. | 17 Oct 1875 | pastor's wife |
| Whitten, Mary | Died | |
| Wilcox, Albert | Jun 1906 | |
| Wilcox, Albert | 6 Jul 1906 | |
| Wilcox, Albert L. | 5 Nov 1911 | |
| Wilcox, Carrie | Jun 1906 | |
| Wilcox, Catherine | 8 Jul 1917 | |
| Wilcox, Charles W. | 10 Sep 1868 | removed to Baptist Church |
| Wilcox, Clara | 6 Jul 1906 | |
| Wilcox, Clarence | 11 Nov 1894 | |
| Wilcox, E. Francis | 22 Mar 1896 | |
| Wilcox, Ellen (Mrs) | 5 Jan 1895 | |
| Wilcox, John | 5 Jan 1895 | |
| Wilcox, Kate | Died 13 Feb 1911 | |
| Wilcox, Kate | ||
| Wilcox, Lottie | 17 May 1896 | |
| Wilcox, Lottie | 17 May 1896 | |
| Wilcox, Lucille | 8 Jul 1917 | |
| Wilcox, Lucy (Mrs) | 14 Jan 1900 | |
| Wilcox, Mollie | Jan 1879 | |
| Wilcox, Mollie | 22 Aug 1910 | |
| Wilcox, Priscilla | 4 Jan ? | removed |
| Wilcox, Ruth | 6 Jan 1895 | removed to Ashland, Illinois |
| Wilcox, Thomas | 6 Jan 1895 | |
| Wilcox, Wallace | 17 May 1896 | |
| Wilcox, Wallace | 17 May 1896 | removed |
| Wilson, Ann | Died 27 Feb 1899 | |
| Wilson, Charles E. | removed | |
| Wilson, Thomas | Died 20 Dec 1915 | |
| Witter, Mary C. | removed | |
| Wright, Emma D. | 11 May 1884 | |
| Wright, Mary B. | 11 May 1884 | |
| Wright, T. B. | 11 May 1884 | |
| Yates, Oliver | 1 Jan 1890 | removed |
| Yates, Teena | 25 Aug 1885 |