Jay County Indiana Biographies
JONAS VOTAW, one of the leading and influential
citizens of Jay County, was born January 1, 1813, near New Lisbon,
Columbiana County, Ohio, being the tenth and youngest child, and the
only one now living, of John and Rebecca (Burson) Votaw. His father
was of French descent, his mother being of Scotch ancestry. They
belonged to the Society of Friends, and were married in a Quaker
church, in Loudoun County, Virginia, in accordance with the usual
custom of that society, the date of their marriage being January 9,
1793. The father was a blacksmith by occupation, and manufactured all
kinds of edged tools then in use, farming utensils, etc. He made the
knives, forks, plates, and also furniture with which he had his wife
began housekeeping. By strict economy and close application to his
trade, he accumulated a little money. In the fall of 1796, they left
their native county, having two horses on which they loaded their
clothing, placing their few goods on pack saddles, crossing the
Allegheny Mountains, and locating in Harrison County, West Virginia,
where the father bought land on which he made his home seven or eight
years. He then sold his land and with his family, then consisting of
wife and six children, he moved to Columbiana County, Ohio, in the
fall of 1803, where he purchased a section of Government land, five
miles west of New Lisbon. He sold 160 acres of this land, retaining 480
acres which he paid for by working at his trade. He was a skilled and
reliable workman, and his patrons came to his shop a distance of from
ten to twenty miles in the early settlement of the country. His son
Jonas, the subject of this sketch, had but limited educational
advantages in his youth, only attending the common district school
four terms of three months each between the age of twelve and sixteen
years. Prior to reaching the age of twelve years he had been taught at
home by his parents. From sixteen until attaining the age of twenty one
years he was engaged in farming on his father's farm. For two years
from the age of twenty-one to twenty-three years he was engaged in
burning wood into charcoal, making 100,000 bushels of charcoal from
about 2,000 cords of wood, and sold the same to Hughes & Doyle, this
firm using charcoal furnaces in the manufacture of iron, nails and
castings. This work was very laborious, requiring constant attention
both night and day, Mr. Votaw having three coal pits burning most of
the time, and not sleeping more than four or five hours during the
day. From this labor of a little over two years he realized a net
profit of $600. Desiring to travel and see more of the world, he made
a safe deposit of his money, and November 1, 1835, contracted with
Captain McIntoch of Wellsville, Ohio, for $40 a month, and was one of
four men to row two large flat boats, 40 x 80 feet, lashed together,
making a surface of 40 x 80 feet. This boat was loaded with different
kinds of produce to supply the wants of the people on the Lower
Mississippi, and the trip, including the coast trade on the lower
Mississippi, embraced a period of almost five months. Although
attended with many exciting incidents, both romantic and dangerous,
such as passing over the falls of the Ohio River at Louisville, and
the eddies and whirlpools of the lower Mississippi, the trip was much
enjoyed. The Captain was an experienced man, this being his nineteenth
trip, and landed them safely at New Orleans February 1, 1836, with his
goods mostly sold. Mr. Votaw remained at New Orleans ten days, viewing
the city, and February 10, 1836, he embarked on a large steamboat,
bound for Louisville with a stock of oranges and lemons, which were
sold inCincinnati, the profit of these more than paying steamboat
fare. He proceeded to Richmond, Indiana, for a short visit to
relatives and friends, and was very favorably impressed with the
country. At that time there was much talk and excitement about the
sale of cheap Government lands at Fort Wayne and Northern Indiana, and
Mr. Votaw resolved to invest his small means in the purchase of lands.
He accordingly returned to his native home, collected his money, and
started on foot and alone for Fort Wayne, Indiana, arriving at his
destination about the middle of May, 1836. He was there informed that
the receiver's office was closed, and would remain so about two
months, and this gave him a good opportunity to explore and prospect
for land. He received much information and kind advice from Mr.
Brackenridge, the Registrar of the land office. After remaining three
days at Fort Wayne he started for the wilds of Northern Indiana,
sometimes going from ten to twenty miles between cabins and
settlements, passing through a part of De Kalb, Noble, and LaGrange
counties, entering the State of Michigan at Sturgis, going on to
Kalamazoo, which at the time had but a dozen small houses. Finding
that the Michigan land had been taken up he returned to Fort Wayne,
and in the meantime he had taken the numbers of forty-six tracts of
land, numbering from first to forty-sixth choice. At this time the
country was full of land hunters, and at the opening of the land
office at Fort Wayne, about July 1, 1836, there were at least 2,000
people in the village, most of whom were land buyers from New York,
Pennsylvania, Indiana and Ohio, and the speculators and money sharks
took advantage of the honest, unsuspecting land buyers, getting the
number of their lands, to come in conflict with them. Then for the
sole purpose of making money they would offer to release and
compromise for $50 or $100, called hush money. Mr. Brackenridge,
seeing how matters stood, gave notice to those desiring to enter land
to prepare their numbers by section, township and range by writing,
and hand the same into his office the following morning, and that no
other entries would be made until those applications were gone through
with, and this to a great extent stopped the land sharks from imposing
on the people. Mr. Votaw had to remain in Fort Wayne fifteen days
before his entries could be reached, he finally entering five eighty
acre lots, four hundred acres in all, his selections being among the
choicest tracts of land, one tract being on the north branch and
another on the south of the Elkhart River. All of said land he sold
within three years of the date of entry, receiving on an average $7
per acre before any tax has accrued thereon, Government land being
exempt from taxation for five years from date of purchase. He had paid
for these lands $1.25 an acre. After closing his purchases at Fort
Wayne Mr. Votaw,with sixteen other eastern land buyers, purchased a
large canoe, in which they floated down the Maumee River to Toledo,
then a village of not more than fifteen houses, and from
there proceeded to Cleveland by steamer, subsequently reaching his home
in Columbiana County, Ohio, with but sixpence in his pocket. The news
of his land purchase created no little excitement among his relatives
and former associates, and in the fall of the same year his father,
John Votaw, his brother-in-law, Preston Beck, and James Ferrel offered
to pay Mr. Votaw's expenses if he would pilot them to Fort Wayne,
which offer he accepted, and all mounted on good horses they soon
arrived at their destination. There learning that the choice land had
all been sold in northern Indiana, they went to Jay County, where they
found an unbroken forest of heavy timber land subject to entry, and
here his father bought 400 acres. Preston Beck 240 and James Ferrel
eighty acres located on the Limberlost Creeknear the present site of
the village of Westchester. These three gentlemen then returned to
their homes, and our subject went to his lands in Noble County, where
he remained over a year, making some improvements, and in the meantime
cut and split 6,000 rails for other parties. He still kept his plats
in Noble, LaGrange and Elkhart counties marked up by sending them to
the registrar of the land office, thus being able at all times to show
the vacant lands to those wishing to purchase, which occupation he
followed when called on. He was an expert woodsman, often making as
high as $5 a day. In the fall of 1837 he was taken sick with bilious
malarial fever, followed by an attack of ague, and on recovering he
returned to his native home in the latter part of 1838. He remained
with his father the following summer and winter, recuperating his
health and helping on the farm. In the fall of 1838 his father, with
his two sons, John, Jr., and Isaac, sold their farms, and in the
spring of 1839 came with our subject to Jay County, Indiana, and
settled on their land near Westchester. The father having money hired
help, and in a little over one year he had fifty acres of cleared
land. In the fall of 1840 he was taken sick with typhus fever and died
September 7, 1840, in his seventy-first year, his death being a source
of great grief to his family. He had left a home, surrounded with all
the necessary comforts of life, and many friends and relatives in
Ohio, where, with such a constitution as his, he might have been
spared for many years. Jonas Votaw, having previously purchased 280
acres of land in the vicinity of Westchester, built a frame house on
his land, and cleared forty acres in 1840-'41. In August, 1841, he was
elected treasurer of Jay County, being nominated by the Whig party. He
was three times re-elected by the people, and held that office twelve
consecutive years, serving with credit to himself and satisfaction to
his constituents. He resigned the office of treasurer June 10, 1853,
he having previously been elected treasurer of the Cincinnati, Union &
Fort Wayne Railroad, which he held four or five years. While treasurer
of Jay County he acted as agent for many non-residents in selling
their lands, buying and selling many tracts of land, and it was a
common saying that "Votaw never bought a poor piece of land, and you
can bet the title thereto is good." He was married September 8, 1842,
to Ann Brown, daughter of Aaron and Mary Brown, and immediately after
his marriage located at Portland, and at once became interested in the
improvement and development of that city. He has since lived in
Portland, or the immediate vicinity, his present residence being about
one mile from the business center. To Mr. and Mrs. Votaw were born
seven children -Wilson C., was born August 10, 1843; August 10, 1861,
he volunteered in Company C, Thirty-ninth Regiment Indiana Infantry;
was a Sergeant of Captain George F. Winter's Company (C), Eighth
Regiment of Indiana Veteran Cavalry Volunteers; was enrolled on the
122th day of February, 1864, to serve three years, or during the war;
was honorably discharged from the service of the United States July
20, 1865, at Lexington, North Carolina, by order of the Secretary of
War; and was married October 21, 1866, to Jane Simmons; Ruth A., born
April 18, 1845, was married in September, 1860, to A.J. Callahan, a
farmer residing near Johnstown, Bates County, Missouri; Mary R., born
May 7, 1847, was married September 20, 1866, to D.A. Henry, a farmer
living near Clinton, Henry County, Missouri; Sarah G., born August 6,
1851, was married September 7, 1879, to J.R. Coulson, a farmer
residing two miles southwest of Portland; Howard E., born December 30,
1853, married November 14, 1885, to Ollie M. Milligan, and is engaged
in farming two miles west of Portland; Homer S., born January 26,
1856, is a ticket and freight agent, and also telegraph operator for
the Chicago & Northwestern Railway Company, now located at Smith's
Mill, Minnesota; John J., born March 10, 1859, died October 23, 1859.
Mrs. Votaw died March 18, 1859, aged thirty-three years, ten months
and twenty-seven days. Mr. Votaw was again married June 17, 1861, to
Lizzie K. Dresser, a daughter of John Dresser, who lived near Old
Stockbridge, Berkshire County, Massachusetts. She had a liberal
education and followed school teaching for several years. She was an
exemplary Christian, a member of the Congregational church. To this
marriage were born five children - James F., born and died June 19,
1862; Clara B., born June 26, 1863, is now clerking for her brother,
Homer S., in the office of the Chicago & Northwestern Railroad Company
at Smith's Mill, Minnesota; Lillian K., born January 22, 1866, was
married April 9, 1887, to John E. Bishop, a teacher in the Portland
City Normal School; Henry J., born September 12, 1867, a teacher in
the Portland Normal School; Emma L., born June 17, 1871. Mrs. Votaw
died July 13, 1874, aged forty-three years, seven months and nineteen
days, and lived and died a devoted Christian. August 10, 1875, Mr.
Votaw married at Little York, Ohio, Mrs. N.J. (Perdew) Case, daughter
of Philip and Amy M. Perdew. Her father was a native of Pennsylvania,
born September 2, 1805, and her mother was born near Providence, Rhode
Island, August 2, 1813. The latter was of French extraction, the third
cousin of Marquis de La Fayette, her maiden name being Des Trees. Mrs.
Votaw is a Christian woman, in early life joining the Methodist
church. She was first married July 9, 1857, when seventeen years of
age, to Augustus B. Case, and to them were born two children -Amy L.,
born June 18, 1858, and died the day of her birth; Cecil E.A., born
May 16, 1880, was married February 19, 1881, to Etta B. White, who
died September 20, 1884, aged twenty-one years. Both were members of
the Christian church. Augustus B. Case was a soldier in the war of the
Rebellion, enlisting in 1861 in the Fifty-fifth Ohio Infantry. He
veteranized January 22, 1864, and was killed at the battle of Reseca,
Georgia, May 15, 1864, at the age of twenty-six years. He was a brave
soldier, and a true Christian. Cecil E.A. Case now lives with his
parents, and is engaged in farming. Jonas Votaw was appointed and
commissioned by Governor Oliver P. Morton director of the Northern
Indiana State Prison to serve for a term of two years, from march 11,
1861, to fill the vacancy caused by the resignation of Colonel Milt.
Robinson, which position he accepted and filled with satisfaction to
the State. He was also postmaster at College Corner, Jay County, for
five or six years, which position he filled satisfactorily for six
years, when the company failed, and was finally dissolved in 1863. The
citizens of Portland and Jay County were heavy losers by the failure
of this enterprise, theyhaving expended about $100,000 in grubbing and
grading the railroad bed from Union City to Portland, Indiana, a
distance of twenty miles. This railroad bed still remains unironed,
but the prospects are that in the near future it will be utilized. Mr.
Votaw was appointed chairman of a commission by a Congress of the
United States, said commission being to partition the Me-shin-go-me-sia
reservation in Grant and Wabash counties, Indiana, under Act of
Congress of June 1, 1872. In said reservation there were about ten
sections of land which had never been surveyed. In the spring of 1873
the commission commenced work and was occupied about ten weeks, by
which time they had sectioned of the land, and divided it per capita
among the band of Me-shin-go-me-sia, consisting of sixty-six Indians,
making each division almost 100 acres. Mr. Votaw took an active
interest in the organization of the Jay County Agricultural,
Horticultural and Industrial Joint Stock Company, which was
incorporated December 1, 1871, with which he has since been identified
either as president or director. The fairs have always proved a
success financially, and the growth and breeds of all kinds of stock
have been greatly improved, and the general interests of the country
have been developed by the society's progressive course. Mr. Votaw was
chosen a delegate from the Eleventh Congressional District of Indiana
to represent said district in the National Republican Convention that
convened in Chicago, June 3, 1884, which resulted in the nomination of
James G. Blaine for President, and John A. Logan for Vice President.
He took an active part to secure the nomination of Mr. Blaine. Mr.
Votaw is a public spirited citizen, and has given liberally of his
means to all public enterprises for the development of the city of
Portland, and the country at large, doing all in his power to secure
railroads to Portland, and gravel roads throughout the county, and has
aided in the support of schools and churches from the early settlement
of the county to the present time. In his religious views he is
liberal and progressive, not recognizing the Jewish ceremonies and
ordinances as essential to salvation.

