| Last Name | First Name | Birth | Death | Cemetery | Notes |
| Baker | James Horace | none given | Oct 06 1885 | Herrington | Aged 6 yrs 7 mo |
| Ballard | Elizabeth A. | 1858 | 1935 | Herrington | Wife of J.W. |
| Ballard | James W. | 1864 | 1950 | Herrington | |
| Burkhardt | Christ | May 22 1858 | Jun 28 1913 | Herrington |
|
| Butler | Tyler Cole | Mar 26 2003 | June 27 2003 | Herrington | "6th Gr Grandson of Bartholomew Herrington" |
| Cadwallader | Charles W | 1857 | 1886 | Herrington |
|
| Cadwallader | Mary F | 1836 | 1903 | Herrington | SSA Charles |
| Cadwallader | Charles | 1814 | 1887 | Herrington | SSA Mary F |
| Cadwallader | Daniel H | 1868 | 1891 | Herrington | Parents John & Josie; SSA Infant |
| Cole | Annie K. | 1871 | 1955 | Herrington | SSA William |
| Cole | William H. | 1870 | 1943 | Herrington | SSA Annie |
| Drinen | Myrtle J | 1904 | 1927 | Herrington | Said "Wife and Mother" on stone |
| Drinnen | Molly | none given | Aug 1921 | Herrington |
|
| E. | T.B. | none given | none given | Herrington |
|
| E.V. |
| none given | none given | Herrington |
|
| Ellis | Edward Lee | Dec 8 1894 | Thur Nov 7 1895 | Herrington |
|
| Ellis | Lilly Bell | Feb 9 1892 | Tue Feb 9 1892 | Herrington |
|
| Etheridge | Bessie | none given | none given | Herrington | Aged 18 days; (no stone found in 2008) |
| Evans |
| 1862 | 1874 | Herrington |
|
| Foosy | August | Aug 15 1852 | Aug 10 1933 | Herrington |
|
| Foster | Alex H | 1859 | 1942 | Herrington | Said "Father" on stone; SSA Millie |
| Foster | Edna M | Oct 14 1883 | Mar 25 1931 | Herrington |
|
| Foster | James | Mar 25 1774 | Jan 3 1867 | Herrington |
|
| Foster | James F | Oct 9 1815 | Nov 5 1887 | Herrington |
|
| Foster | Mary | Jan 26 1791 | Feb 23 1857 | Herrington |
|
| Foster | Millie F | 1863 | 1929 | Herrington | Said "Mother" on stone; SSA Alex |
| Fuchs | Jack | May 15 1951 | Jun 28 1988 | Herrington | "For his restoration of this Cemetery" "Body donated to Science" |
| Goode | Emma | Aug 22 1854 | Feb 2 1908 | Herrington | nee Foster |
| Greenlee | Elijah | 1864 | 1938 | Herrington | SSA Maggie M. |
| Greenlee | Maggie M | 1874 | 1926 | Herrington | same stone as Elijah |
| Held | Irvin | 1916 | 1917 | Herrington |
|
| Herrington | B. | none given | Sep 28 1821 | Herrington | In his 82nd yr of his age |
| Herrington | Bartholomew | April 10 1740 | Sep 28 1821 | Herrington | D.A.R. Plaque |
| Herrington | Elizabeth | none given | Mar 16 1817 | Herrington | In the 90th yr of her life |
| Herrington | Joshua | May 27 1800 | Sep 14 1883 | Herrington | "Erected by his daughter Margaret" |
| Herrington | Sarah Drennan | Apr 26 1800 | Oct 15 1868 | Herrington | D.A.R. Plaque, Daughter of Revolutionary Soldier, William Drennan;
"Moved from Belews Creek" |
| Jeude | Louis | Aug 29 1838 | Sep 10 1896 | Herrington |
|
| Johnston | M. M. | none given | May 17 1886 | Herrington | Aged 53y 9m 4d; (stone not found in 2008) |
| Keeby | Ida M | 1855 | 1925 | Herrington | SSA Wm. Parrish |
| Keith | Douglas C | none given | Mar 4 1896 | Herrington | Son of T.N. & M.; Aged 1 yr 4 mo 18 days |
| Keith | Elder R | Sep 2 1873 | Apr 19 1893 | Herrington | Son of N.& G. Keith |
| Marler | Carrie Ann | Jun 21 1887 | May 8 1932 | Herrington | Said "Wife, Beloved Mother & Grandmother" |
| Marler | Christina | 1920 | 1931 | Herrington | SSA George |
| Marler | Frank | Jun 3 1882 | Aug 8 1957 | Herrington | Said "Father" on stone |
| Marler | George | 1929 | 1931 | Herrington | SSA Christina |
| Marler | Philip T | 1866 | 1932 | Herrington |
|
| Morris | Mary | none given | Nov 8 1890 | Herrington | Aged 75 yrs; (stone not found in 2008) |
| Ogle | Thomas | Apr 18 1828 | Nov 17 1892 | Herrington | SSA Virginia; "Father" |
| Ogle | Virginia | Sep 16 1837 | Mar 22 1920 | Herrington | SSA Thomas; "Mother" |
| Parrish | Wm T | 1854 | 1926 | Herrington | SSA Ida M Keeby |
| Potter | Winnfred M | 1903 | 1935 | Herrington |
|
| Raney | Mary C | none given | Sep 20 1910 | Herrington | Aged 78 yrs 7 mo 20 days |
| Reece | Logan | 1867 | 1931 | Herrington |
|
| Rodemich | Bonnie Fults | Jan 10 1922 | Oct 8 2008 | Herrington | SSA Emmett & John |
| Rodemich | Emmett B | Apr 15 1904 | Feb 18 1994 | Herrington | SSA Bonnie & John |
| Rodemich | John E | Apr 25 1953 | Aug 20 1981 | Herrington | SSA Bonnie & Emmett |
| St. John | Ethel S | Jan 16 1888 | Jul 30 1888 | Herrington | Daughter of John & Josie; SSA Infant |
| St. John | Infant | Aug 30 1891 | Aug 31 1891 | Herrington | Infant of John & Josie; SSA as Ethel |
| St. John | Jennie | Jan 03 1898 | Jul 10 1901 | Herrington | Daughter of John & Josephine |
| Vandiver | Wm. | Jul 21 1822 | Feb 22 1865 | Herrington | Aged 42y 7m 1d |
| Wolff | William Walter | Oct 23 1881 | Mar 18 1889 | Herrington |
|
| Y. | L.H. | none given | none given | Herrington | footstone in area of Louis Jeude |
| Y. | P.A. | none given | none given | Herrington | footstone in area of Louis Jeude |
| Yeida | Josh | Aug 19 1850 | Jan 05 1910 | Herrington |
|
