Baptist Marriage Records
of the Reverend Stephen Case [ 1818-1895] of Greensville NY, Mt Salem, NJ, etc
The two indexes below were created from data gleaned from the Orange County Genealogical Society, Goshen NY Newsletter.
There are two Indexes, one sorted by Bride, the second sorted by Groom. There are a lot of other marriages in the Newsletters, but I only indexed those where the residence of either the Bride or Groom was listed as New Jersey. If you are interested in other marriages performed by the Rev Case, I am happy to send scans.
| Groom | Groom's Residence | Bride | Bride's Residence | Date | Notes |
| Wood, Abraham P | Vernon, NJ | Ayers, Jane | Wantage | Dec 8 1860 | |
| VanSickle, Andrew Jackson | Wantage | Ayers, Maggie A | Frankford, NJ | Feb 16 1867 | |
| Roloson, Amsey J | Wantage | Ayers, Mariah | Wantage | Nov 7 1855 | |
| Burroughs, Nelson | Sussex Co., NJ | Bedell, Sarah Jane | Greenville, NY | Jan 7 1862 | |
| Rogers, William H | Wantage | Beemer, Ella | Wantage | Aug 13 1870 | |
| Longcor, Anthony | Wantage | Beener, Phebe Elizabeth | Wantage | Sep 22 1857 | |
| Alward, Isaac T | Wantage | Benjamin, Martha | Wantage | Jan 23 1847 | |
| Dillistin, Daniel | Wantage | Bowman, Esther Maira | Wantage | Dec 19 1863 | |
| Casterline, Benjamin | Wantage | Brink, Lydia | Wantage | Jan 8 1849 | |
| Hockenberry, Petter | Wantage | Brink, Sarah M | Wantage | Nov 18 1854 | |
| Mead, Ralph | Wantage | Bross, Charity E | Wantage | Jun 11 1874 | |
| Snider, Leonard | Wantage | Brown, Sarah Maria | Wantage | Aug 25 1848 | |
| Snook, Peter | Waterloo Mills NY | Burwell, Catharine Elizabeth | Wantage | Feb 9 1860 | |
| Winfield, Lewis | Wantage | Carpenter, Emily | Wantage | Oct 16 1852 | |
| Myers, J Harrison | Greenville, NY | Carr, Mary Catharine | Wantage | Nov 9 1870 | |
| DeBaum, James | Bloomingdale, NJ | Case, Julia Ann | Minisink, NY | Dec 30 1848 | |
| Baird, Charles E | Greenville, NY | Caskey, Cornelia | Wantage | Jul 4 1874 | |
| Decker, Henry | Wantage | Casterlin, Cynthia | Wantage | Jul 4 1854 | |
| Kinsey, Charles | Patterson, NJ | Casterlin, Harriet | Wantage | May 12 1858 | |
| Cole, James I | Wantage | Casterline, Sarah E | Montague, NJ | Dec 24 1859 | |
| Elston, Daniel S | Greenville, NY | Clark, Mary Ann | Wantage | Mar 21 1863 | |
| Ayers, Jonathan | Somerset Co., NJ | Coddington, Martha | Wantage | Sep 11 1847 | Dau of Jeremiah Coddington of Wantage |
| Cole, Moses [Deacon] | Wantage | Coddington, Mary | Greenville, NY | Feb 17 1855 | |
| Carman, Joseph | Wantage | Cole, Catharine | Montague, NJ | Dec 24 1859 | |
| Clark, Jonathan H | Wantage | Cole, Eleanor Ann | Wantage | Nov 12 1853 | |
| Vail, Tionothy | Wantage | Cole, Emily Jane | Wantage | Oct 7 1858 | |
| Vail, Sanford | Wantage | Cole, Hannah | Wantage | Mar 14 1850 | |
| McCoy, Samuel | Wantage | Cole, Mary Elizabeth | Wantage | Sep 28 1861 | |
| Cortright, Alva J | Wantage | Cole, Sarah E | Wantage | Feb 3 1859 | |
| Winters, Levi | Greenville Twp, NY | Cole, Sarah Maria | Wantage | Mar 7 1854 | |
| Beemer, Lewis D | Wantage | Concor, Amanda M | Wantage | July 28 1857 | |
| Baily, Wm H | Wantage | Cortright, Alice | Wantage | Nov 26 1872 | |
| Stanton, James N | Mt Hope, NY | Cortright, Lydia E | Wantage | Nov 11 1863 | |
| Wickham, Thomas Youngs | Greenville, NY | Corwin, Emeline | Wantage | Jun 7 1865 | Son of Halsey & Rebecca Youngs Wickham |
| Coykendall, Sanford | Wantage | Courtright, Lizaie K | Wantage | Jul 30 1868 | |
| Latteer, Moses B | Wantage | Courtwright, Esther | Wantage | Sep 1 1849 | |
| Howell, Noah | Wantage | Courtwright, Katharine | Wantage | Jan 24 1850 | |
| Cole, Richard D | Coleville, NJ | Coykendall, Julia Ann | Coleville, NJ | Dec 29 1858 | |
| Coleman, Nelson | Wantage | Davenport, Amanda | Wantage | Mar 1 1860 | |
| Spencer, James N | Wantage | Davenport, Catharine | Wantage | Nov 4 1848 | |
| VanSickle, Wm C | Wantage | Decker, Emily | Wantage | May 17 1851 | |
| Baird, David Decker | Wantage | Decker, Mary I | Wantage | Oct 19 1872 | |
| Casterlin, Nathaniel Jr | Wantage | Dennis, Jane | Unionville | Feb 14 1861 | |
| Corwin, Benjamin F | Wantage | Detch, Julia A | Greenville, NY | Apr 29 1869 | |
| Casterlin, Wm E | Wantage | Dewitt, Lavina | Wantage | Jun 19 1872 | |
| Merrifield, William | Hyde Pk, Scranton, PA | Dodd, martha Frances | Franklin Twp, Somerset, NJ | Dec 3 1874 | |
| Mulhern, Peter | Wantage | Dunning, Huldah | Wantage | Jan 1 1848 | Dau of Absalon Dunning [late of Wantage] |
| Cole, Wm H | Wantage | Eckert, Roseanna | Wantage | Jan 4 1851 | |
| Case, Joshua Jr | Greenville, NY | Elston, Maranda Jane | Wantage | Nov 10 1867 | Joshua, 'My youngest son' / Dau of David Elston of Wantage |
| Haughwout, Joseph [Rev] | Wantage | Elston, Mary [Mrs] | Minisink | Sep 7 1847 | |
| Wickham, Abraham | Wantage | Elston, Mary Jane | Greenville, NY | Nov 24 1859 | Son of Davis Conklin Wickham & Fanny Cortright |
| Mead, Harvey E | Port Jervis, NY | Elston, Sarah E | Mt Salem | Apr 19 1871 | |
| Clark, Albert Alonzo | Wantage | Everett, Frances Amelia | Wantage | Aug 3 1867 | |
| Wainwright, Jacob S | Sussex Co., NJ | Everett, Hetty | Sussex Co., NJ | Jan 13 1852 | |
| Lewis, Britten | Wantage | Everett, Polly | Wantage | Mar 24 1853 | |
| Sickles, Ogden F | Sparta, NJ | Foster, Rose | Branchville, NJ | Oct 8 1874 | Dau of Harvey P & Susan Foster |
| Fredericks, Peter R | Montague, NJ | Fuller, Alice | Montague, NJ | Jan 10 1872 | |
| Casterlin, Abraham B | Montague, NJ | Fuller, Isabella | Montague, NJ | Mar 26 1864 | |
| Vail, Daniel | Wantage | Gilson, Rosanna | Coleville, NJ | Sep 19 1866 | |
| Perry, Gabriel | Wantage | Gunsoly, Mary E | Greenville, NY | Nov 26 1864 | |
| VanSickle, Jacob | Wantage | Hardin, Matilda | Wantage | Dec 15 1869 | |
| Elston, Erastus | Wantage | Haughwout, Mary [Mrs] | Greenville, NY | May 10 1856 | |
| Eolfe, Samuel C | Wantage | Hockenberry, Ann Eliza | Wantage | Nov 28 1855 | |
| Roloson, Thomas N | Wantage | Hoffman, Maggie A | Wantage | Feb 2 1871 | |
| Cortright, Erastus | Minisink, NY | Hoyt, Clarissa Jane | Wantage | Oct 31 1863 | |
| Elston, Ebenezer M | Minisink, NY | Hoyt, Kesla [Mrs] | Wantage | Oct 14 1848 | |
| Elston, James H | Wantage | Hoyt, Mary Jane | Wantage | Feb 20 1851 | |
| Wyant, Nathan Y | Wantage | Huffman, Elcy Ann | Wantage | Jun 11 1854 | |
| Struble, Peter | Wantage | Kilpatrick, Phebe | Wantage | Oct 30 1847 | Dau of John Kilpatrick |
| VanSickle, Bowdewine C | Minisink, NY | Lateer, Nerinda | Wantage | Feb 6 1867 | |
| Sweeny, John | Wantage | Little, Hannah | Wantage | Apr ?? 1854 | |
| Kithcart, Daniel D | Sussex Co., NJ | Little, Isabel | Sussex Co., NJ | Jan 8 1853 | |
| O'Halahan, Patrick | Wantage | Longsey, Hannah Jane | Wantage | Oct 23 1847 | |
| Vail, Horace | Montague, NJ | Mandeville, Sophia | Wantage | Oct 13 1860 | |
| Dunn, Moses | Wantage | Martin, Jane | Wantage | Dec 6 1849 | |
| Elston, Joseph W | Wantage | Mather, Hannah E | Wantage | Sep 18 1867 | |
| Cortright, John B | Greenville, NY | Mathers, Deborah | Wantage | Jul 3 1871 | |
| Moffets, Jeremiah | Greenville, NY | McManus, Ruth | Wantage | Apr 13 1864 | |
| Elston, Wm | Wantage | Mead, Julia | Wantage | May 16 1867 | |
| Doty, Peter H | Wantage | Mead, Mary E | Wantage | Nov 25 1854 | |
| Middaugh, Wm | Wantage | Mead, Sarah | Wantage | Jan 16 1856 | |
| Cole, John Case | Wantage | Middaugh, Julia Ann | Wantage | Feb 20 1858 | |
| Benjamin, Thomas W | Wantage | Middaugh, Maggie Ophelia | Wantage | Feb 25 1869 | |
| Westfall, Charles | Wantage | Myers, Hannah Jane | Minisink, NY | Jan 12 1854 | |
| House, Daniel | Sussex Co., NJ | Myers. Elizabeth | Minisink | Dec 25 1861 | |
| Benjamin, Lewis D | Wantage | Owen, Anna Mary | Wantage | Dec 31 1867 | |
| Conklin, John | Wantage | Perry, Eleanor | Wantage | Feb 26 1848 | |
| Coykendall, Daniel L | Wantage | Perry, Julia Ann | Wantage | Nov 25 1848 | |
| Beemer, Alva | Wantage | Richards, katharine | Wantage | Dec 27 1851 | |
| Coykendall, Decker | Wantage | Richards, Sarah Ann | Wantage | Oct 21 1848 | |
| Hardin, Isaac C | Wantage | Rodgers, Sarah C | Wantage | Jan 1 1868 | |
| Havens, Samuel S | Wantage | Roe, Cornelia | Wantage | Sep 11 1867 | |
| Roloson, Harvey | Wantage | Roloson, Mary | Wantage | Oct 26 1847 | Dau of James Roloson |
| Roberts, Malcon [Rev] | Chataugua Co., NY | Roloson, Phebe | Wantage | Oct 16 1847 | |
| Collard, William S | Newark, NJ | Roloson, Rosetta | Beemersville, NJ | Sep 30 1863 | |
| Crane, Wm B | Wantage | Roloson, Sarah C | Wantage | Nov 7 1855 | |
| Carpenter, Horace | Wantage | Rutan, Lydia | Wantage | Jul 16 1853 | |
| Carpenter, Lebeus L | Wantage | Rutan, Rebecca I | Wantage | Dec 24 1853 | |
| Everett, Geroge | Minisink, NY | Seely, Ache [Mrs] | Wantage | Oct 13 1848 | |
| Winters, Byram Webster | Wantage | Seybolt, Marietta | Greenville, NY | Jun 10 1874 | |
| Decker, Alanson O | Wantage | Simmons, Martha | Lafayette, NJ | May 24 1860 | |
| Mead, Jacob W | Mt Salem | Skinner, Elizabeth | Mt Salem | Aug 21 1858 | |
| Feazler, John F | Wantage | Smith, Rosilla | Wantage | Mar 5 1859 | |
| Roloson, Daniel | Wantage | Snook, Phebe Jane | Frankford, NJ | Nov 16 1859 | |
| Elston, Charles | Minisink, NY | Space, Mary Elizabeth | Wantage | Feb 14 1852 | |
| Williams, John B | Middletown, NY | Springstead, Mary E | Libertyville, NJ | Mar 6 1856 | |
| Compton, William C | Wantage | Still, Nancy [Mrs] | Wantage | Jul 26 1847 | |
| Gillson, James O | Wantage | Totten, Martha Q | Warren Co., NJ | Dec 14 1871 | |
| Detterer, John | Sussex Co., NJ | Townsend, Margaret | Sussex Co., NJ | Sep 15 1849 | |
| Forest, Henry | Port Jervis, NY | Townsend, Mary | Wantage | Oct 27 1870 | |
| Pierce, Henry | Port Jervis, NY | Townsend, Samantha | Wantage | Oct 10 1871 | |
| Bross, Oliver L | Wantage | VanGorder, Lucinda | Wantage | Jan 18 1851 | |
| VanAuken, James | Sussex Co., NJ | VanHousen, Julia E | Orange, NY | Oct 19 1848 | |
| Richards, Oren B | Wantage | VanSickle, Asanath | Wantage | Sep 8 1863 | |
| Cook, James H | Wantage | VanSickle, Clarissa W | Wantage | Sep 14 1854 | |
| Lewis, Edward L | Wantage | VanSickle, Emily C | Wantage | Apr 23 1855 | |
| Smalley, Calvin I | Wantage | VanSickle, Marjaret Jane | Wantage | Apr 28 1860 | |
| Roloson, Horace J | Wantage | VanSickle, Mary jane | Wantage | Jan 1 1853 | |
| Post, James E | Coleville | VanSickle, Susie P | Wantage | Feb 10 1872 | |
| Wainwright, Wallace | Sussex Co., NJ | Wainwright, Lanah | Sussex Co., NJ | Dec 21 1848 | Married at Greenville, NY |
| Beemer, Evi | Wantage | Wickham, Phebe | Wantage | Feb 3 1853 | Dau of William & Maria Kirkendall Wickham |
| Moore, Thomas M | Wantage | Wickham, Sara Jane | Wantage | Jan 3 1873 | Youngest Dau of Samuel Wickham |
| Wilson, James G | Wantage | Wickham, Sobriny Jane | Wantage | Dec 12 1850 | Dau of William Wickham, Jr |
| Clark, David M | Wantage | Wilcox, Ruame | Wantage | Dec 1 1869 | |
| Everitt, Noah | Wantage | Winfield, Katharine | Wantage | Oct 3 1858 | |
| Mann, Kelfy | Wantage | Woodward, Emily [Mrs - Young Widow | Wawwayanda | Nov 9 1986 | Colored - "my first of this color" |
| Groom | Groom's Residence | Bride | Bride's Residence | Date | Notes |
| Alward, Isaac T | Wantage | Benjamin, Martha | Wantage | Jan 23 1847 | |
| Ayers, Jonathan | Somerset Co., NJ | Coddington, Martha | Wantage | Sep 11 1847 | Dau of Jeremiah Coddington of Wantage |
| Baily, Wm H | Wantage | Cortright, Alice | Wantage | Nov 26 1872 | |
| Baird, Charles E | Greenville, NY | Caskey, Cornelia | Wantage | Jul 4 1874 | |
| Baird, David Decker | Wantage | Decker, Mary I | Wantage | Oct 19 1872 | |
| Beemer, Alva | Wantage | Richards, katharine | Wantage | Dec 27 1851 | |
| Beemer, Evi | Wantage | Wickham, Phebe | Wantage | Feb 3 1853 | Dau of William & Maria Kirkendall Wickham |
| Beemer, Lewis D | Wantage | Concor, Amanda M | Wantage | July 28 1857 | |
| Benjamin, Lewis D | Wantage | Owen, Anna Mary | Wantage | Dec 31 1867 | |
| Benjamin, Thomas W | Wantage | Middaugh, Maggie Ophelia | Wantage | Feb 25 1869 | |
| Bross, Oliver L | Wantage | VanGorder, Lucinda | Wantage | Jan 18 1851 | |
| Burroughs, Nelson | Sussex Co., NJ | Bedell, Sarah Jane | Greenville, NY | Jan 7 1862 | |
| Carman, Joseph | Wantage | Cole, Catharine | Montague, NJ | Dec 24 1859 | |
| Carpenter, Horace | Wantage | Rutan, Lydia | Wantage | Jul 16 1853 | |
| Carpenter, Lebeus L | Wantage | Rutan, Rebecca I | Wantage | Dec 24 1853 | |
| Case, Joshua Jr | Greenville, NY | Elston, Maranda Jane | Wantage | Nov 10 1867 | Joshua, 'My youngest son' / Dau of David Elston of Wantage |
| Casterlin, Abraham B | Montague, NJ | Fuller, Isabella | Montague, NJ | Mar 26 1864 | |
| Casterlin, Nathaniel Jr | Wantage | Dennis, Jane | Unionville | Feb 14 1861 | |
| Casterlin, Wm E | Wantage | Dewitt, Lavina | Wantage | Jun 19 1872 | |
| Casterline, Benjamin | Wantage | Brink, Lydia | Wantage | Jan 8 1849 | |
| Clark, Albert Alonzo | Wantage | Everett, Frances Amelia | Wantage | Aug 3 1867 | |
| Clark, David M | Wantage | Wilcox, Ruame | Wantage | Dec 1 1869 | |
| Clark, Jonathan H | Wantage | Cole, Eleanor Ann | Wantage | Nov 12 1853 | |
| Cole, James I | Wantage | Casterline, Sarah E | Montague, NJ | Dec 24 1859 | |
| Cole, John Case | Wantage | Middaugh, Julia Ann | Wantage | Feb 20 1858 | |
| Cole, Moses [Deacon] | Wantage | Coddington, Mary | Greenville, NY | Feb 17 1855 | |
| Cole, Richard D | Coleville, NJ | Coykendall, Julia Ann | Coleville, NJ | Dec 29 1858 | |
| Cole, Wm H | Wantage | Eckert, Roseanna | Wantage | Jan 4 1851 | |
| Coleman, Nelson | Wantage | Davenport, Amanda | Wantage | Mar 1 1860 | |
| Collard, William S | Newark, NJ | Roloson, Rosetta | Beemersville, NJ | Sep 30 1863 | |
| Compton, William C | Wantage | Still, Nancy [Mrs] | Wantage | Jul 26 1847 | |
| Conklin, John | Wantage | Perry, Eleanor | Wantage | Feb 26 1848 | |
| Cook, James H | Wantage | VanSickle, Clarissa W | Wantage | Sep 14 1854 | |
| Cortright, Alva J | Wantage | Cole, Sarah E | Wantage | Feb 3 1859 | |
| Cortright, Erastus | Minisink, NY | Hoyt, Clarissa Jane | Wantage | Oct 31 1863 | |
| Cortright, John B | Greenville, NY | Mathers, Deborah | Wantage | Jul 3 1871 | |
| Corwin, Benjamin F | Wantage | Detch, Julia A | Greenville, NY | Apr 29 1869 | |
| Coykendall, Daniel L | Wantage | Perry, Julia Ann | Wantage | Nov 25 1848 | |
| Coykendall, Decker | Wantage | Richards, Sarah Ann | Wantage | Oct 21 1848 | |
| Coykendall, Sanford | Wantage | Courtright, Lizaie K | Wantage | Jul 30 1868 | |
| Crane, Wm B | Wantage | Roloson, Sarah C | Wantage | Nov 7 1855 | |
| DeBaum, James | Bloomingdale, NJ | Case, Julia Ann | Minisink, NY | Dec 30 1848 | |
| Decker, Alanson O | Wantage | Simmons, Martha | Lafayette, NJ | May 24 1860 | |
| Decker, Henry | Wantage | Casterlin, Cynthia | Wantage | Jul 4 1854 | |
| Detterer, John | Sussex Co., NJ | Townsend, Margaret | Sussex Co., NJ | Sep 15 1849 | |
| Dillistin, Daniel | Wantage | Bowman, Esther Maira | Wantage | Dec 19 1863 | |
| Doty, Peter H | Wantage | Mead, Mary E | Wantage | Nov 25 1854 | |
| Dunn, Moses | Wantage | Martin, Jane | Wantage | Dec 6 1849 | |
| Elston, Charles | Minisink, NY | Space, Mary Elizabeth | Wantage | Feb 14 1852 | |
| Elston, Daniel S | Greenville, NY | Clark, Mary Ann | Wantage | Mar 21 1863 | |
| Elston, Ebenezer M | Minisink, NY | Hoyt, Kesla [Mrs] | Wantage | Oct 14 1848 | |
| Elston, Erastus | Wantage | Haughwout, Mary [Mrs] | Greenville, NY | May 10 1856 | |
| Elston, James H | Wantage | Hoyt, Mary Jane | Wantage | Feb 20 1851 | |
| Elston, Joseph W | Wantage | Mather, Hannah E | Wantage | Sep 18 1867 | |
| Elston, Wm | Wantage | Mead, Julia | Wantage | May 16 1867 | |
| Eolfe, Samuel C | Wantage | Hockenberry, Ann Eliza | Wantage | Nov 28 1855 | |
| Everett, Geroge | Minisink, NY | Seely, Ache [Mrs] | Wantage | Oct 13 1848 | |
| Everitt, Noah | Wantage | Winfield, Katharine | Wantage | Oct 3 1858 | |
| Feazler, John F | Wantage | Smith, Rosilla | Wantage | Mar 5 1859 | |
| Forest, Henry | Port Jervis, NY | Townsend, Mary | Wantage | Oct 27 1870 | |
| Fredericks, Peter R | Montague, NJ | Fuller, Alice | Montague, NJ | Jan 10 1872 | |
| Gillson, James O | Wantage | Totten, Martha Q | Warren Co., NJ | Dec 14 1871 | |
| Hardin, Isaac C | Wantage | Rodgers, Sarah C | Wantage | Jan 1 1868 | |
| Haughwout, Joseph [Rev] | Wantage | Elston, Mary [Mrs] | Minisink | Sep 7 1847 | |
| Havens, Samuel S | Wantage | Roe, Cornelia | Wantage | Sep 11 1867 | |
| Hockenberry, Petter | Wantage | Brink, Sarah M | Wantage | Nov 18 1854 | |
| House, Daniel | Sussex Co., NJ | Myers. Elizabeth | Minisink | Dec 25 1861 | |
| Howell, Noah | Wantage | Courtwright, Katharine | Wantage | Jan 24 1850 | |
| Kinsey, Charles | Patterson, NJ | Casterlin, Harriet | Wantage | May 12 1858 | |
| Kithcart, Daniel D | Sussex Co., NJ | Little, Isabel | Sussex Co., NJ | Jan 8 1853 | |
| Latteer, Moses B | Wantage | Courtwright, Esther | Wantage | Sep 1 1849 | |
| Lewis, Britten | Wantage | Everett, Polly | Wantage | Mar 24 1853 | |
| Lewis, Edward L | Wantage | VanSickle, Emily C | Wantage | Apr 23 1855 | |
| Longcor, Anthony | Wantage | Beener, Phebe Elizabeth | Wantage | Sep 22 1857 | |
| Mann, Kelfy | Wantage | Woodward, Emily [Mrs - Young Widow | Wawwayanda | Nov 9 1986 | Colored - "my first of this color" |
| McCoy, Samuel | Wantage | Cole, Mary Elizabeth | Wantage | Sep 28 1861 | |
| Mead, Harvey E | Port Jervis, NY | Elston, Sarah E | Mt Salem | Apr 19 1871 | |
| Mead, Jacob W | Mt Salem | Skinner, Elizabeth | Mt Salem | Aug 21 1858 | |
| Mead, Ralph | Wantage | Bross, Charity E | Wantage | Jun 11 1874 | |
| Merrifield, William | Hyde Pk, Scranton, PA | Dodd, martha Frances | Franklin Twp, Somerset, NJ | Dec 3 1874 | |
| Middaugh, Wm | Wantage | Mead, Sarah | Wantage | Jan 16 1856 | |
| Moffets, Jeremiah | Greenville, NY | McManus, Ruth | Wantage | Apr 13 1864 | |
| Moore, Thomas M | Wantage | Wickham, Sara Jane | Wantage | Jan 3 1873 | Youngest Dau of Samuel Wickham |
| Mulhern, Peter | Wantage | Dunning, Huldah | Wantage | Jan 1 1848 | Dau of Absalon Dunning [late of Wantage] |
| Myers, J Harrison | Greenville, NY | Carr, Mary Catharine | Wantage | Nov 9 1870 | |
| O'Halahan, Patrick | Wantage | Longsey, Hannah Jane | Wantage | Oct 23 1847 | |
| Perry, Gabriel | Wantage | Gunsoly, Mary E | Greenville, NY | Nov 26 1864 | |
| Pierce, Henry | Port Jervis, NY | Townsend, Samantha | Wantage | Oct 10 1871 | |
| Post, James E | Coleville | VanSickle, Susie P | Wantage | Feb 10 1872 | |
| Richards, Oren B | Wantage | VanSickle, Asanath | Wantage | Sep 8 1863 | |
| Roberts, Malcon [Rev] | Chataugua Co., NY | Roloson, Phebe | Wantage | Oct 16 1847 | |
| Rogers, William H | Wantage | Beemer, Ella | Wantage | Aug 13 1870 | |
| Roloson, Amsey J | Wantage | Ayers, Mariah | Wantage | Nov 7 1855 | |
| Roloson, Daniel | Wantage | Snook, Phebe Jane | Frankford, NJ | Nov 16 1859 | |
| Roloson, Harvey | Wantage | Roloson, Mary | Wantage | Oct 26 1847 | Dau of James Roloson |
| Roloson, Horace J | Wantage | VanSickle, Mary jane | Wantage | Jan 1 1853 | |
| Roloson, Thomas N | Wantage | Hoffman, Maggie A | Wantage | Feb 2 1871 | |
| Sickles, Ogden F | Sparta, NJ | Foster, Rose | Branchville, NJ | Oct 8 1874 | Dau of Harvey P & Susan Foster |
| Smalley, Calvin I | Wantage | VanSickle, Marjaret Jane | Wantage | Apr 28 1860 | |
| Snider, Leonard | Wantage | Brown, Sarah Maria | Wantage | Aug 25 1848 | |
| Snook, Peter | Waterloo Mills NY | Burwell, Catharine Elizabeth | Wantage | Feb 9 1860 | |
| Spencer, James N | Wantage | Davenport, Catharine | Wantage | Nov 4 1848 | |
| Stanton, James N | Mt Hope, NY | Cortright, Lydia E | Wantage | Nov 11 1863 | |
| Struble, Peter | Wantage | Kilpatrick, Phebe | Wantage | Oct 30 1847 | Dau of John Kilpatrick |
| Sweeny, John | Wantage | Little, Hannah | Wantage | Apr ?? 1854 | |
| Vail, Daniel | Wantage | Gilson, Rosanna | Coleville, NJ | Sep 19 1866 | |
| Vail, Horace | Montague, NJ | Mandeville, Sophia | Wantage | Oct 13 1860 | |
| Vail, Sanford | Wantage | Cole, Hannah | Wantage | Mar 14 1850 | |
| Vail, Tionothy | Wantage | Cole, Emily Jane | Wantage | Oct 7 1858 | |
| VanAuken, James | Sussex Co., NJ | VanHousen, Julia E | Orange, NY | Oct 19 1848 | |
| VanSickle, Andrew Jackson | Wantage | Ayers, Maggie A | Frankford, NJ | Feb 16 1867 | |
| VanSickle, Bowdewine C | Minisink, NY | Lateer, Nerinda | Wantage | Feb 6 1867 | |
| VanSickle, Jacob | Wantage | Hardin, Matilda | Wantage | Dec 15 1869 | |
| VanSickle, Wm C | Wantage | Decker, Emily | Wantage | May 17 1851 | |
| Wainwright, Jacob S | Sussex Co., NJ | Everett, Hetty | Sussex Co., NJ | Jan 13 1852 | |
| Wainwright, Wallace | Sussex Co., NJ | Wainwright, Lanah | Sussex Co., NJ | Dec 21 1848 | Married at Greenville, NY |
| Westfall, Charles | Wantage | Myers, Hannah Jane | Minisink, NY | Jan 12 1854 | |
| Wickham, Abraham | Wantage | Elston, Mary Jane | Greenville, NY | Nov 24 1859 | Son of Davis Conklin Wickham & Fanny Cortright |
| Wickham, Thomas Youngs | Greenville, NY | Corwin, Emeline | Wantage | Jun 7 1865 | Son of Halsey & Rebecca Youngs Wickham |
| Williams, John B | Middletown, NY | Springstead, Mary E | Libertyville, NJ | Mar 6 1856 | |
| Wilson, James G | Wantage | Wickham, Sobriny Jane | Wantage | Dec 12 1850 | Dau of William Wickham, Jr |
| Winfield, Lewis | Wantage | Carpenter, Emily | Wantage | Oct 16 1852 | |
| Winters, Byram Webster | Wantage | Seybolt, Marietta | Greenville, NY | Jun 10 1874 | |
| Winters, Levi | Greenville Twp, NY | Cole, Sarah Maria | Wantage | Mar 7 1854 | |
| Wood, Abraham P | Vernon, NJ | Ayers, Jane | Wantage | Dec 8 1860 | |
| Wyant, Nathan Y | Wantage | Huffman, Elcy Ann | Wantage | Jun 11 1854 |
| Baptist Records |
| Case, Stephen, Rev - 1818 - 1895 |
| Marriages performed in New Jersey [Probably Mt Salem] |
The following Index was created from the Orange County, NY Newsletter [Various Editions]
There are a lot of Marriages recorded, I selected only those where either the Bride or Groom's residence was in New Jersey.
If you have an interest in the other folks married by the Reverend Stephen Case, I am happy to send scans of the pages.
I created two Indexes, the irst is sorted by Bride, the second is sorted by Groom.
Site Created: 03 January 2008 Martha A Crosley Graham Rights Reserved - 2008
