NOTE: Names marked with an asterick (*) are from a list made by Raymond
B. Traver in 1916 but which could not be authenticated by this writer.
The double asterisk (**) indicates that a monument was in its original
position in 1959.
ANDREWS, Frances Amelia, dau of Hubert 1836 - 1850 ATWELL, Hiram, d. 3/4/1849; ae 33 yrs AUMOCK, Amelia *, d. 1859 Johannah* AVERY, Charlora M. * BAKER, Elisha F., son of (prob. Vincent) and Lavina, d. 11/26/1854; ae 7-10-16 BARDEN, Albert**, son of A.J. and P.A., d. 5/25/1849; ae 5-9-25 BARKER, Eddy* Levi* BARLOW, Azor W., d. 2/23/1848; ae 47-5-11 BARNS, Mary, wife of Isaac, d. 3/4/1849; ae 88 yr Isaac, d. 12/18/1824; ae 67 BEACH, William & Sally, children of William and Sally; "Born and died 26 and 21 June 1829" BENNETT, Jane, d. 7/10/1847, in the 63rd year of her age BENNETT, Ann **, d. 12/30/1845, ae 32; buried in Wm. Stevens lot BENNETT, Polly, L. **, dau of Janes and Fanny, d. 7/4/1849; ae 5-9-12 BENTLEY, Rev. Samuel, d. 3/9/1823; ae 37-1 Jane, his wife, d. 11/28/1865; ae 81-4-25 BIBBENS, Daniel E. **, d. 1/23/1856; ae 54 Susan, his wife, dau. of Peter and Mary Douglass; d. 11/10/1843; ae 30-0-10 Mary M., daughter, d. 2/12/1844; ae 1-2-14 Sarah Ann, dau. of Daniel E. and Lucia Ann, d. 4/15/1842; ae 7-11 All are buried in Peter Douglass lot BIBBENS, Rev. Samuel, d. 1/7/1836; ae (possibly 77) Abraham, son of Rev. S. and A., d. 7/9/1826; ae 31 William, son of Rev. S. and A., d. 4/6/1826; ae 27 BIBBENS, Anna*, probably wife of Rev. Samuel BISHOP, Henry, son of Stephen and Catherine, d. 7/29/1854; ae 26 BLANCHARD, George *, d. 1860 BOTSFORD, Elizabeth, wife of John L., d. 1/30/1839; ae 43-4-2 BRIGGS, Henry, d. 1/1/1838; ae 29 (b. 1809) Sally, his wife, d. 2/10/1838; ae 28 (b. 1810) BRIGGS, Jane Ann, wife of J.H., d. 8/23/1837; ae 22 (b. 1815) Emily S., wife of John J., d. 1/2/1842; ae 23 (b. 1819) BRITTON, Martha *, d. 1856 BROWN, Althea * BROWN, James H., d. 1849; ae 1 yr BURNS, James, D. 4/28/1813; ae 40 Joseph, d. 11/13/1831; ae 36-10 BUTLER, Alvira, wife of (probably Zacheus), d. 3/14/1854; ae 48-11-9 BUTTRE, Elizabeth, dau. of William and Mary Ann, d. 6/15/1827; ae 4 yrs BUTTRE, Mary * BUTTRE, Mary Anne ** CAIN, Susan, wife of William, d. (prob.) 2/22/1839; ae 42 CALHOUN, James H. **, d. 12/17/1850; ae 15; son-in-law (?) of Peter Douglass and buried in his lot CARPENTER, Dorcas, d. 3/24/1843; ae 57 CARPENTER, Elizabeth, wife of Beriah, d. 7/29/1822; ae 68-5-? CARSON, Caleb, d. 2/14/1855; ae 20 CHADDERDON, Phebe Ann, wife of Nathan, d. 5/18/1843; ae 22-4-21 CHAPIN, Lorenzo, son of Orlando and Lydia, d. 5/23/1830 or 36; ae 26 CHRISTIAN, Jeremiah H., d. 8/11/1856; ae 39 CLOW, Henry *, d. 1851 COOK, Charles Henry, son of P.R. and Harriet, d. 2/25/1828; ae 0-1-7 COOL, Henry, d. 2/9/1861; ae 38-8-6 CORNELL, Phillip "Who departed this life 12/26/1831 ae 35-9-6" "If the affections of a fond wife would have detained him then would he have been detained" CORNWELL, Eden B., d. 8/22/1833; ae 67 CRAM, J.H. *, d. 1854 CRONK, Emiline * CRONK, William H., d. 7/3/1840; ae 50-9 CROSS, Platt **, Co. K 3d NY Art CROSS, Benjamin (Prob), d. 7/1/1859; ae 12-10-17 CUTLER, William *, d. 1848 DEAN, Josiah (prob. called Joseph in Traver list), b. 8/28/1833, d. 2/10/1851; ae 17-5-10 DEAN, Joseph * (see above) Lydia * DEAN, Mary Jane, dau. of Polly R., d. 11/3/1837; ae 1-?-? DOUGLASS, Peter **, d. 9/11/1861; ae 85-8-25 Mary, his wife, d. 12/8/1852; ae 69-1-22 John H., son, d. 7/18/1805; ae 4 wks Jane, dau. , d. 10/31/1820; ae 9-0-9 Eliza, dau., d. 10/7/1839; ae 30-3-3 Merinda, dau., d. 2/6/1842; ae 34-4-28 See Daniel E. Bibbens and James H. Calhoun. On the large family monument Mary is given as the mother of all four children. However, on the individual monuents Eliza's mother is given as Mary but the mother of John and Jane is listed as Polly. Note birth dates. Polly was doubtless Mary's nickname. Peter Douglass and Polly Hamilton are traditionally the first couple to have been married in Brutus Township. DURKEE, William B. *, d. 1854 ELDREDGE, Eliza * EMRICK, John, d. 7/12/1857; ae 85 Jane, his wife prob., d. 1847 EMRICK, Margaret * FAATZ, Almira * FAATZ, Charles * FAATZ, Francis H., d. 1837; ae 3-10-? George W., d. 6/27/1842 (prob.); ae 0-10-10 Children of Jacob and Laura FELLOWS, ___, son of Alonzo, Sr., d. ae 18 yrs (in parentheses handwritten note says father was Elisha K.) FIELD, Amos, d. 4/13/1825; ae 13 FIELD, Samuel C., son of Spafford and Sally, d. 12/3/1824; ae 0-13-10 FILLEY, Edwin R., son of Henry R. and Emma, d. 6/25/1842; ae 18-1-1 FILLEY, Emma Amelia, dau. of H. and E., d. 3/27/1827; ae 0-14-7 FINK, Helen Lucetty, wife of Edmund A., d. 4/19/1842; ae 20-9-17 FITCH, Olive, wife of Wm. R. and dau. of Joseph and Sarah Hamilton FOLLETT or FOLLET, Capt. David, d. 8/27/1839; ae 72 Tryphena his wife, d. 1/12/1820; ae 52 FOLLETT, David N., d. 5/13/1854; ae 52-3-14 FORMAN, Thomas *, d. 1844 FORRIST, Ira, son of Oliver and Catherine, d. 8/21/1827; ae 19 FREEMAN, Albert * FREEMAN, Oscar S., son of W. and Lucinda, d. 1/27/1856; ae 12-5 FRISBIE, Augustus *, d. 1840 GATLIN, Francis *, d. 1851 GILDERSLEEVE, ___er, d. 1846 GOFF, John, d. 3/24/1858; ae 56-10-10 ____, his wife, d. 10/17/1864 in her 66th year GRANGER, Susannah, d. 1818 (a home-made stone) GRIFFIN, Maria **, wife of William, d. 7/28/1837; ae 23-3-18 HAMILTON, John, d. June ( prob 2), (1806 prob.); ae 76 or 78 yrs, 8 or 9 mo and 9 da HAMILTON, Deacon Joseph, d. 10/9/1819; ae 73-5-9 Sarah, his wife, d. Dec 15 or 17, ? Sarah, daughter, d. 2/8/1804; ae 22-7-4 HAMILTON, William, d. 7/9/1826; ae 55 Elizabeth, his wife, d. 6/21/1829; ae 51 HAVENS, Elizabeth, wife of F.D., d. 4/6/1853; ae 19-4 HAVENS, Mary S., wife of D.E., d. 6/18/1849; ae 38-11-20 Mary Adelaide, their daughter, d. 1/21/1845; ae 7-6 HASELTINE, David, only son of Daniel (or David) and Elizabeth, d. 8/30/1828; ae 19 HENRY, Samuel, d. 4/17/1841; ae 63 HEWITT, Sarah C., dau. of Thomas and Sarah, d. 9/4/1832; ae 7-8 HOLLERN, Gaffy * Georgia * Simon * HOPKINS, Amelia * Harriet * Joseph * HOUGHTON, Maria, wife of Rev. Royal, d. 3/5/1836; ae 29 HOWARD, Samuel *, d. 1852 HOYT, Francis C., son of Isaac and Phebe, d. 10/6/1852; ae 2-4-24 HOYT, Samuel, d. 11/12/1852; ae 74-4 HOYT (prob.), Samuel, d. 10/?/?; ae 67 HUSTED, Mary Andrews, wife of J.D., 1826-1856 or 58 JOHNSON, ___ **, child of E.P. and J., d. 1/13/1854; ae 0-10-4 JOHNSON, James *, d. 1854 JOHNSON, Stephen, d. 3/12/1855; ae 75 JONES, Anna Maria, dau. of Caleb and Jane D., d. 12/4/1848; ae 3-6-23 KINNE, David, d. 7/1/1855; ae 68-1 Dorcas, his wife (possibly April) 26, 1840 or 49 KERBY, Polly *, d. 1821 KERNAN, Clarence * LATHROP, Elizabeth d. 9/19/1831; ae 59-6-6 LEE, Delia, wife of John G., d. ?/26/184? LEE, Henry *, d. 1854 Martha *, d. 1847 LEGG, Asenath, wife of John, d. 2/18/1865; ae 35 Edward, son, d. 8/8/? LEGG, Emma *, d. 1853 LITTLE, Almira, wife of Thomas, d. 9/6/1843; ae 31-2-28 LORD, Jesse, d. 11/8/1820; ae 28-3 Hilan D., son of Jesse and Hannah, d. 2/27/1823; ae 9-3-6 LORD, Orange B. *, d. 1823 LUCKEY, Eliza * MALTBIE, Rodman J., son of Seth and Lydia, d. 9/7/1824; ae 0-15 MARKS, ___ *, d. 1831 MOORES, Daniel *, d. 1861 Hannah * Lewis *, d. 9/8/1836; ae 64 MOORES, Susan C., dau. of D.H. and L., d. 8/2/1851; ae 5-5-6 MOREHOUSE, Jane, wife of John, d. 3/16/1873; ae 81 MORSE, Daniel E., son of David H. and Laura, d. 10/25/1864; ae 14 MUNROE, Triphena, d. 10/7/1856; ae 75 NESBITT, Martin *, d. 1852 Mary * NETTERVILLE, Mary *, d. 1851 NYE, Fanny, dau. of George and Abigail, d. 8/31/1827; ae 16-5-21 OCOBOCK, Elizabeth, wife of Peter, Jr., d. 8/11/1841; ae 21 OLDS, Elsa A., dau. of Henry A. and Mary, d. 5/18/1858; ae 22 OLDS, Nathan *, d. 1848 OLNEY, Eliza S. Eldredge, wife of Oliver A., d. 3/9/1860; ae 26-0-16 PAGE, Henry *, d. 1853 Julius *, d. 1852 PARR, Josephine *, d. 1850 PASHBY or PASHLEY, Mary * PASSAGE, Betsy Ann, wife of David, d. 1/23/1853; ae 32-0-28 PASSAGE, Mary, wife of S.A., d. 10/24/1864; ae 25 Carrie, daughter, d. 1/18/1865; 2 yr PASSAGE, Charles L., son of Adam and Orilla, d. 12/27/1851; ae 6-0-13 PASSAGE, James L. *, d. 1851 PATTEN, Rebecca * POND, Willie, son of M.S. and J.A., d. 6/20/1858; ae 5-6-18 POPPLE, Betsy A., wife of Theodore, d. 12/16/1841; ae 43 POPPLE, Mary B. Sprague, "Formerly wife of James Popple, deceased", d. 11/30/1827; ae 39-3-27 POPPLE, Theodore, Esq. * POTTER, Amelia Ann, dau. of Ezekiel and Eliza A., d. 12/31/1871; ae 24-5-11 PUTNAM, Lewis, d. 1/11/1832; ae 63 Nancy, his wife, d. 3/18/1845; ae 71-0-28 RAYNOR, John, d. 7/16/1856; ae 70 Ann, dau. of James and Betsy, d. 7/18/1819; ae 3 wks. Almira, dau. of J. and B., d. 8/22/1844; ae 2-2-16 RICE, Ann Elizabeth, dau. of W. and C., d. 2/12/1835; ae 7-2 RICE, Woodis, d. 4/26/1841; ae 51-9-26 ROBINSON, David M., d. 12/2(3)/186(?); ae 15-10-19 ROBINSON, Moses, d. 12/28/1820; ae 37-6-15 (note see page 73 of cemetery notebooks) ROBINSON, Sarah * (prob. later burial in Rural Cemetery) ROGERS, Ira * ROOD (see RUDE and RUDES) ROOD, Aaron G., d. 4/4/1856; ae 52-11-6 ROOT, Sarah M., dau. of Rev. Edward and Lucretia, d. 1/15/1848; ae 13-11- RUDE, Anna, wife of John J. B., Esq., d. 10/12/1851; ae 55-2 (handwritten note says to see Rude Diary) RUDE, Caleb, d. 3/2/1829; ae 74-9-15, "The second man who settled in this town, 1800" Martha, his wife, d. 3/11/1823; ae 57 RUDE, Charles B. * (handwritten note says son of Jason and Elmira, 1840 - 1855) RUDE, Hiram * RUDE, John * RUDE, Jonah, b. 12/20/1751, d. 11/30/1825 Eleanor, b. 4/28/1751, d. 5/30/1826 RUDE, Lewis, d. 6/28/1851; ae 25-11-20 RUDE, Sarah, wife of Myron B., d. 2/26/1853; ae 51-5-11 Myron Augustus, son, d. 2/9/1856; ae 21-9 RUDE, Nathan, d. 7/21/1839; ae 58-0-15 ___, son of Nathan and Polly, d. 1/3/1846; ae 18-5?-10 Daniel D., son of N. and P., d. 9/20/1840; ae 24-11-5 RUDE, Sarah * RUDE, William * RUDES, Gen. Orange, d. 3/31/1830; ae 50-6-12 Phebe, his wife, d. 8/31/1830; ae 58 RUDES, Samuel, son of H.B. and Sarah, d. 1/9/1842; ae 0-3-16 RUNDELL, Emily Pardee, wife of W.W., d. 9/25/1834 RUNDELL, Mary, wife of Darius P., d. 8/11/1824; ae 21-1-25 St. JOHN, Alderetta *, d. 1851 St. JOHN, Bayles E., son of E. and E.M., d. 2/17/1849; ae 5-7-8 Emma C., dau. of Eron and E.M., d. 5/2/1853; ae 3-3-12 Lydia E., dau. of E. and E.M., d. 8/14/1848; ae 0-9-19 St. JOHN, Carolina and Marshall * St. JOHN, John, d. 4/26/1854; ae 89-9-11 Amarilla, his wife, d. 1/1/1849; ae 70-1-20 SAMPLE, Almira **, 1823 -1886 Catherine, 1800 -1882 Samuel W., 1798 - 1849 Elizabeth, 1839 - 1840 SAMPSON, Eliza, wife of Peter, d. 3/29/1837; ae 32 SARGENT, Daniel * SCHOONMAKER, Sarah, wife of Hon. John, d. 3/1/1848; ae 51-1-10 SCOTT, Fannie * SHEARSTON, Charles C., son of Edward and Maria, d. ?/1/1858; ae 1-?-? SHEPHERD, Althea, "Relic of S. Shepherd, widow of C. Brown and dau. of Rev. S. and A. Bibbins, died 4/24/1862 in her 73rd year" SHELDON, Eli, d. 7/25/1824; ae 50-2-2 SMITH, Eliza, dau. of Jesse J. and Elizabeth, d. 3/19/1846; ae 27-9 SOONER, Mary and Henry *, d. 1857 SPAFFORD, Samuel * SPOONER, John B., d. 12/7/1856; ae 56-14-7 Mary H., dau. of John and Fanny, d. June 1855; ae 0-14 SPRAGUE, Mary*, d. 1827 STEEL, Welthy, wife of (prob. William ), d. Mar 1825; ae 19 Orson, son of William, d. 1/5/1825; ae 0-6-27 STEVENS, Levi, son of John, d. 6/13/1836; ae 21-11-6 STEVENS, Nancy *, d. 1853 STEVENS, William **, d. 12/15/1862; ae 86 Patience, his wife, d. 3/14/1828; ae 48 Bennett, "The first child born at Macedonia, 1/13/1801", d. 2/17/1847; ae 45 Olive, d. Feb 1840; ae___, wife of Bennett Perry, d. 9/22/1841; ae 24 See Ann Bennett STEVENS, William * STONE, Ezra **, d. 7/5/1849; ae 50-3-13 Electa, his wife, d. 4/ prob. 5/ 1864; ae 58-0-6 Sobrina, his first wife, d. 4/28/1829; ae 26-1-2 Lemon C., son of Ezra and Sobrina, d. 4/ prob. 5/ 1833; ae 1-7-27 (there must be an error with this date or Sobrina's date) STONE, Leman, d. 4/2/1826; ae 28-8-2 STREETER, Mary E., dau. of J.B. and Adaline, d. 8/23/1846; ae 1-2- STREETER, Naomi, wife of Nathan SWEETLAND, infant dau. of W.W. and E.W., d. 1/28/1854; ae 0-0-6 THOMPSON, Ira D., d. 2/24/1858; ae 35-3-4 TAYLOR, Mary * TITUS, Cecelia, wife of Smith, d. 1/14/1833; ae 25-0-23, "Also buried with her their two infant children" TRAVER, John *, d. 1864 TRAVER or TRAVERS, Roxana, wife of John, d. 2/19/1859; ae 38-8-6 Infant son, d. 3/31/1859 or 50; ae 0-2-1 Margaret Angelica, d. 2/21/1849; ae 1-11-29 TURNER, Ebenezer W. Nancy B., his wife Marinda D. or O., d. 8/22/1856; ae 1-6-5, daughter Amelia M., daughter, d. 11/19/1838; ae 5-11-20 Cornelia Z., daughter, d. 7/26/1843; ae 2-11-9 Edgar A., son, d. 9/6/1848; ae 4-11-12 Charles H., son, d. 8/28/1854; ae 2-2-15 TYLER, infant* d. 1854 VALENTINE, Sarah E., dau. of M.L. and A.W., d. 9/18/1850; ae 1-3-11 WARREN, Lucy, "Our Mother", d. 6/29/1811; ae 48-3-28 WATERMAN, Polly A. *, d. 1845 WATSON, John * Elizabeth *, 1959 tombstone survey "...... of John Watson, d. 6/10/1841 in the 59th year of her age" WELCH, Andrew *, d. 1857 WOOD, Florence J., dau. of C.H. and J.C., d. 5/21/1855; ae 5-3 WOODEN, Harman * WOODWORTH, Silas, d. 1839 WOOLLEY, Abigail, dau. of (prob. P. or F.) S. and P. or F., d. 8/26/1856; ae 0-0-6
Re: Albert Barden, son of A.J. and P.A. Barden:
Albert's father Allen Barden (son of Jacob and S. Barden and born
1818 in Seneca County) was a carpenter and mechanic. Allen's wife
Polly's maiden name may have been Halstead. Allen and Polly had two
younger daughters, Helen (b. 1847) and Florence (b. 1849). The Bardens
moved from Weedsport to the nearby city of Auburn, NY by the early
Thanks to Martha S. Magill for transcribing the information on this
page into a digital format.
Photo images of some remaining headstones were provided in November 2010 by Tammy Schramm
Bernie Corcoran, Cayuga County