Located on Rte 62 Between Kennedy and Frewsburg.
Still in use no recent burials found, but some stones in place for living family.
This data is mostly from my own attempt to read these old stones, in a cold
wind, watery eyes, and very eroded stones and many missing I have tried to track.
This is to be used ONLY as a guide, there are NO other records for this we
can find except the data submitted by Kelley Raymond , use them together.
Read October 31, 2000
Submitted November 2, 2000
Dee Davidson
ANDERSON
Double marker
Alo F or ALOF 1895-1979
Jessie E 1903-1940
next to
Baby Clifford Anderson 1922 ae 10 days
BELLAMY
Jarvis 1837- 1904 Civil War Veteran
I found no record for service but a pension, given to wife Christine, 1904
and he was awarded pension for disability, 4/1/1887 served M 11 NY Cav and
Old War ?
He is listed in Chautauqua Co Civil War records as BELWAY , Jarvis, Carroll,
CC-10
BENSON
This soldiers stone is in very poor condition, broken and glued but very
eroded and almost impossible to read, He is buried very close to the THAYER
and McNELL
Horatio BENSON, died 4/9/1865 Civil War
*Horatio P Benson
Enlist Date 28 August 1862 Busti, NY rank Private age 33
Served New York Enlisted 7th Co. 1st SS Reg. NY died at Jamestown, NY on 16
March 1865
Source: New York: Report of the Adjutant-General
A pension was filed by Louisa WILLSON, GDN(for a minor probably
Grandmother)June 9 1865
BINGHAM
Vine T. 12/27 178? born Reheboth died 7/26/183? there is a crack through the
stone, which lies flat in the ground and will soon be covered with sod
same stone, Wife Elizabeth died 7/13/1842 ae 44 she is only BINGHAM in the
1840 census Carroll
also next to and also in ground is
Laura J dau of Samuel and Belinda BINGHAM born in Carroll 11/18/1847 died
7/2/1861 beside her sister
Ida M dau of Samuel and Belinda born in Carroll, 1861-1865
BINGHAM
Monument says only Bingham, near is 3 smaller stones;
G.W. 1826-1896
Melinda 1831-1898
Emma ae 4 no dates
Town records also state George BINGHAM died 4/2/1898
BRAGG
Joshua 1825-1883
Mary A wife, 1830-1902
another stone near probably Benjamin, d 1861
BRAGG
Monument
This monument is poor shape,
Calvin 1804-1878
Mary M. 1808-1895
Charles M. 1840- 1857
(I could not read the death dates for Mary or Charles, they are worn off
from records)
Also in Town records no stone found is
BRAGG
Bragg, Isaac died 1861 age 8 Son of James ad Harriet
BRAGG Harriet
Bragg, James
BRAGG
Bragg, Joseph Sept. 25, 1826-Dec. 27, 1879
Bragg, Amy Aug 1, 1821-Jan 21 1885
Bragg, John b 1800 d 1880 Small double marker
wife Betsey d 1879
BROWN
Double
Henry S 1841-1929
Kate B. 1869-1960
BROWN
Double plot, no marker but 2 home made signs,
no dates
George W, Brown
Naomi KIBBE Brown
BUNCE
Monument says only Bunce
4 smaller stones around
Julia M Bunce 1889-1964
Frances E Bunce 1859-1910
Edgar F 1887-1974
Lester F 1844-1914
CAMPBELL - POPE
John born Voluntown CT 3/31/1781
Died 8/27/1814
Beside him is buried the 2 children of Jedediah POPE and wife Roxanna
CAMPBELL his wife
dau died 8/30/1844 ae 5 months 9 days
Infant dau d 10/23/1846 ae 1 month
(*Notes, Jedediah POPE married in the town of Carroll, 1 Roxanna CAMPBELL
was born in Voluntown CT 1814 dau of John and Molly Campbell and beside
this CAMPBELL, John is another marker for
Mehitable G. POPE, born Burlington, Otsego NY March 4, 1799 came to
Chautauqua 9/22/1833 died 9/22/1880 Beside her is another crumbled stone,
not able to read at all but is probably the Jedediah POPE her husband he
died in 1850 These are all in the same area of the Hiram and Chester POPE
here below )
COMSTOCK
1 monument for Asa COMSTOCK, states "Probably killed in a VA prison" ,
Civil War Soldier
stone in memory and town records say he is not here but buried on a battle
field September 7, 1842 died August 22, 1863
Asa Comstock Enlist Date 15 August 1862 at Carroll, NY rank Private age 19
Served New York Enlisted C Co. 9th Cav Reg. NY (No further record)
Asa was Asa Nathaniel COMSTOCK, born Frewsburg, the Son of Martha STONE
and Orsino COMSTOCK also buried here, their stones have been broken and
are in very poor condition Town records say Orsino died 1861 Martha his
wife died 1891
Also here are Eliza Anna COMSTOCK died 1838(*family data / she is the 1st
wife of Orsino COMSTOCK and Dau of Eliza Anna , Betsey died 1839 File also
ids her as Anna ELiza EDWARDS b 26 JUN 1817 -- WINDSOR, NEW YORK the
daughter of Jasper EDWARDS and Elizabeth "Betsey" QUICK)
DAVEY - BROOKS
Double beside and matches the Henry Brown marker
Katherine B 1891-1971
Eva D 1908-1978
COVEY
John COVEY died 1866 no age can be read, war of 1812 beside Child William
No date
COWAN
very tall monument has toppled and been glued
George W. 1/26/1802 d 2/27/1881
Esther L 1/21/1814 died 9/3/1884
Behind this monument is 4 small markers
Infant Martin, 9/20/1893
E.L. COWAN no data
Sally and John COWAN
C.W. COWAN no dates
and another row of 5 matching markers/ excellent condition
Samuel COWAN 1790-1847 War of 1812
Edna POPE COWAN 1804-1883
Marshall A Cowan b/d/1847
Lucy J, 1838-1839
Charlotte E. 1843-1852
COWAN
Large letters, "Daughter"
Virginia R Cowan 1913-1931
COWAN
Allen L. Son of George, died 11/15/1873 ae 20-3-17
Charles L died 6/4/1872 ae 21-3-17 there are engravings but eroded may be
brothers
area with missing stone, some traces still there
beside
COWAN
John M son of George d 9/14/1862 ae 20 Killed, Civil War No flag holder
found
Leroy V. D. 11/14/1864 Killed, Civil War no flag holder
Beside 2 small Childs markers for COWAN children of George
7-10-1854 and the other is completely eroded
COWAN
Single marker for each matching;
Clarence M Cowan 1849-1915
Amy L 11/4/1844 died 7/22/1857
Beside small childs marker Infant son, b/d/5/10/1847
These 3 beside a large double marker for
COWAN
James, 2/6/1807 died 11/9/1882
Wife Hannah POPE 6/5/1818 died 8/2/1888
DARLING
Phebe Jane, wife of Charles H Darling died 12/29/1868
Horace AEDIE Darling no date (as spelled on stone)
EAMES
A tall and still beautiful monument on the front is a man and woman hands
clasped, and the following
Isaac EAMES and Betsey WOODARD United for Life, August 17, 1800
side 2
Isaac EAMES born Holliston MA July 1, 1773 died at Carroll NY June 11, 1860
e 86-11-0
Side
side 3
Betsey WOODARD wife of Isaac, born Orange MA May 14, 1774 died at Carroll NY
May 14, 1847 aged 82-7-0
Beside is son
Isaac EAMES Jr died Feb 16, 1831 ae 18-8-10
This monument is directly in front of Hiram and Maryette EAMES THAYER below
ELDRIDGE
Spelled in large letters but the names are
Emir BUNCE 1869-1929
Lafayette 1863-1930
EMERY
Monument
Nathan Emery 11/11/1823 d ``/5/1887
Wife Emeline TAYLOR 4/11/1826 died 10/15/1908
Beside this monument is 3 small stones, 1 each for Nathan and Evaline, one
for Elizabeth,
and also engraved on the face of this small stone is
Emery GARFIELD b 7/2/1826 died 1/23/1874/ she is Elizabeth EMERY GARFIELD
Sister of Nathan and dau of Luther EMERY and Hannah CLARK also here
EMERY
Double marker
Luther, died 3/10/1866 no age /eroded
Wife Hannah died 12/28/1851 ae 59
(* notes, Luther was born 10/21/1794 Hannah is Hannah CLARK born 10/7/1795
in Vermont )
GRAVES
Winford died 4/15/1876 ae 5-7-1
GROUT
Large monument
Martin, 1851-1934
Wife Minnie L 1863-1945
Coralyn L 1891-1970
GROUT
Monument
Louise, 1847-1898
GROUT
Double marker
Emery M 1887-1965
Edith B 1809-1978
Other living GROUT family markers in place
HENDRICKSON
Walter 11/5/1869 - 3/27/1941
HERRICK
Florence E Dau of Can't read died 2/10/1851 no age can be read
HOLMES
William P 1841-1918
Wife Alfredine D 1855-1917
JOHNSON - TAYLOR
4 names 1 marker
Aroline Johnson, (as spelled) 1868-1917
Coralyn TAYLOR 1863-1944
Clarence Taylor 1856-1934
John O. Johnson buried SC no dates
beside is Small double
TAYLOR
Lynn B 1873-1972
Inez P 1890-1975
KELSEY
John died 3/22/1845 ae 58-7-6
KERRIN
3 matching stones
Frank T 1891-1927
Anna S 1895-1961
Raymond, "Red" 1909-1981 flagholder, F.L.T.
MARSH
Monument
Alonzo MARSH 3/23/1824 died 1/2/1892
Probable dau Ellen Wife of Fenn BUNCE same monument 10/15/1846 died
12/5/1880
McNELL
Calvin B. 1/23/1922 died 1/4/1993 US Army, WWII this bronze marker is
beside the Thayer stone for Frank E and Phebe F THAYER below
PAGE
Double
J. Fred 1890-1944
Sadie L 1890-19xx
beside marker for
Robert Page 6/23/1922 died 5/15/1945 WWII flag holder and marker
PAGE
Large monument
John G 1853-1921
Wife Mary GILBERT 1859-1951
In front is 2 small stones that are matching the monument,
Rosetta, 1829-1911
Moses F 1820-1896
POPE
a very tall, over 10' monument to a beloved son
Hiram D POPE Youngest son of Chester G and Sarah (Dickinson) POPE died
November 18, 1861 at age 15-0-11
engraved in fine etching is the following message;;
Dearest Hiram, Thou art gone;
He who was so much loved by parents, brothers, sisters, distant friends and
neighbors too.
He has left these loving friends mournful , sad and lorn, to struggle
through this world without his soothing tone.
OH Why, was he severed from them in his bloom, and his mind enshadowed by
deaths silent gloom?
While vision of hope on his path, seemed to shed a brighter ray, Like a
meteor, Dear Hiram, has passed away.
POPE
Chester G. POPE (father of Hiram) died March 16, 1872 ae 54
Wife Sarah DICKINSON died October 26, 1869 ae 50 "Home to God"
PUTNAM
Mary Jane, w/o PUTNAM dau of ? OSGOOD died 11/28/1871 ae 36
QUAINTANCE
Small monument and it's very eroded all names here from this one stone
James 4/1/1807 d 3/25/1861
Elvira 10/27/1817- d 3/27/1890
Other side is James and John and cannot be read
James Sr is in the 1850 Carroll census
SCOTT
These are in very worn cond.
Charles S.56-1876
Linnie b 184? died ? 30/1880
Child John died 1868
SCOTT
Nancy A wife of David scott died 1/21/1854 looks like age reads 12 or 17 yrs
SCOTT
Asa died 9/1857 ae 58
Polly died 5/1851 ae 55
Louise died 1851 stone missing, name from town records
SMEDLEY
This monument to a small girl is only a few feet from the Hiram Pope
monument, and they match, this one only a bit shorter
Ernestine, Youngest daughter of William and Esther SMEDLEY died 9/24/1861
aged 9-10-16
Sweet faded flower,
We would not ask thy stay
to droop and wither
in a world like this,
when purer spirits beckon thee away
To share with them, a home of perfect bliss
SMITH
Stone in ground and no record is grass covered
Beside another almost buried stone for
Martha Wife of A.J SMITH died 4/16/1866 ae 43-11-25STAPLES Monument is carved to look like a tree Goodwin STAPLES 1828-1904 Wife Alvira P. 1831-1891 STAPLES Elihu 4/19/1838 died 10/21/1892 Civil War Veteran Beside, stone is flat in ground says only Charles H STAPLES? Daniel very eroded but the only records for ANY Daniel are all Staples THAYER Double marker Frank E. 1889-1962 Phebe F 1888-1965 Dau, her bronze marker is touching their stone Major Margaret M. THAYER 5/31/1913 died Feb 10. 1999 WWII Veteran Major, United States Army THAYER Esther M 1891-1988 THAYER small marker Henry Eddie Thayer s/o HiramE and Mary born 7 Mar. 1860 died 10/29/1865 Beside Double marker THAYER Hiram E. 1838-1907 Wife Mary C LAWTON 1840-1913 (*My notes; HIRAM E. THAYER.born 8 May, 1838 Fifth child of Hiram and Maryette Thayer, married Mary C. Lawton, of Carroll, Chautauqua Co., N. Y., 3 July, 1859, and settled in that place. Farmer, and speculator in oil wells. Children are: 1. Henry Eddy, born 7 Mar. 1860 2. Louisa Eliza, born 19 June, 1862) THAYER Large stone, Excellent condition Isaac Warren THAYER 2/5/1832 died 9/21/1902 Wife Lucy Ann COWAN 9/16/1839 died 12/19/1889 (* Notes ISAAC W. THAYER.b 5 Feb. 1832 Second child of Hiram and Maryette Thayer, married Lucy A. Cowen, daughter of John and Hannah Cowen, 16 September, 1861, and settled in Carroll, Chautauqua Co., N. Y. Farmer. One child: a. Amy Cornelia born 10 Dec. 1853) Beside is Patience Stone COMSTOCK THAYER 1855-1914 dau of Orsino COMSTOCK + Martha STONE THAYER tall monument, side 1 Hiram THAYER and Mary EAMES United for life, April 10, 1826 side 2 Mary EAMES born Dover Vermont, May 7, 1810 died at Carroll NY Dec 6, 1879 ae 69-7-0 "Asleep in Jesus, Blessed Sleep" side 3 Hiram THAYER born Ware MA August 24, 1798 died in Carroll NY Jan 10, 1881 ae 82-4-0 (*family notes HIRAM THAYER. Seventh child of Jedediah and Rachel Thayer, married Maryette Eames, of Carroll, Chautauqua Co., N. Y., 10 April, 1828, by James Hill, J. P., and settled in Frewsburg, same Co. Children are: 1. John M., born 20 July, 1829 2. Isaac W., " 5 Feb. 1832 3. Mary A., " 28 Feb. 1834 4. Eliza L., " 21 Feb. 1836 Died 28 Nov., 1856. 5. Hiram E., born 8 May, 1838 6. Ezra Emmons, born 29 July, 1840 died buried here Dec. 2, 1910 Wife Alvira died 1/16/1876 ae 33/1/3/ beside THAYER children Fred E 1881-1882 1 stone missing Sibyl E 1898-1909 Mabel S Thayer 1879-1909 7. Sybil B 7 Sep. 1843 8. Miriam E., " 29 Jan. 1846 9. Orris E., " 1 Oct. 1848 10. Edson Frank.,Thayer " 26 Apr. 1851 is buried here as Frank, 1915 THAYER Triple marker Royal E 1891-1975 Mary F 1893-1966 Ruth E 1901-1985 Beside Elsie M THAYER 1856-1932 She may be a Thayer wife, there is a stone missing and a shrub and flowers planted in the space beside her TIBBETTS or TIBBITS Aurelia, wife of Thomas died 12/2/1872 ae 72, Her stone is fallen flat and is almost covered over TOWNS 10 ft monument 1 side William L Towns d 6/2/1829 ae 3? cannot read the full age Frank O. W. d 3/15/1855 ae 8 mos 29 days side 2 Jeremiah Towns d 3/2/1872 ae 90-11-11 Wife Sene d 2/16/1851 ae 66-10-0 side 3 Stephen D 5/23/1868 ae 61-6/? Wife Nancy eroded their sons William L and Frank and also eroded data In front of this marker is a broken stone, name not known died11/4/1862 ae 22 no flag visible WIGREN C.A. 1863-xx not etched in (records from town list Charles no date) Tillie M (MATILDA) 1859-1933 WIGREN Double John A 1897-1959 Frewsburg Fire Dept Allean, 1897-1991 beside Leroy F Wigren US Army, bronze marker, 8/23/1928 5/21/1993 YAGER In the rear of the cemetery is an area, marked by a large perennial garden that has been lovingly planted and cared for and there are shrubs, and all sorts of flowers, it's in a semi circle shape and in the very center is a large flag pole and the flag flowing in the wind. this is the burial place of Susan B YAGER born April 26 1935 died May 11, 1996 Do not stand at my grave and weep I am not there, I do not sleep I am a thousand winds that blow; I am the diamond glint on snow I am sunlight on ripened grain; I am the gentle autumns rain. When you waken in the morning's hush, I am the swift, uplifting rush Of quiet birds in circled flight. I am the soft star that shines at night. Do not stand at my grave and cry, I am not there, I did not die. Author Unknown
SOURCE: Compiled by Dolores Davidson, and submitted, 2000.