Schoharie County NYGenWeb Site

Argusville Cemetery
adjoining the Lutheran Church
Town of Carlisle, Schoharie County, NY

latitude 42 47' 20" N; longitude 74 30' 52" W
view Google location map

Listings on this page are not necessarily complete and may not represent all of the stones in this cemetery. Please send additional submissions and corrections to Doug Boyer

The following is a listing of the readable stones that are in this cemetery. A number of
the headstones are broken, missing, or there is no lettering left to read. The present
church was erected in 1855 but has been closed since the 1970's. The cemetery is still
mowed. Harriet Geywits
 
ACKERLY, James H. 2/19/1868 24y 9m 21d
ALPAUGH, Benjamin 1824-1883
     Gitty Gordon, wife 1823-1912(?)
     Mary Jane 1854-1876
ALPAUGH, Eliza M., Daughter of Morris & Marguret Alpaugh 12/4/1862  12y 2m 20d
ARNOLD, Joseph H. 8/9/1899 77 yrs 10 m 16d
BELLINGER, Anna M. Killmartin wife of Austin J. Bellinger 1886 - 1905
BRIDGMAN, Rev. A. L.  5/16/1813 - 3/12/1888
     Mary Ann, wife  2/22/1817 - 1/5/1892
BRUNICK, David L. 1851 - (no date)
     Mary G. SIMON  1852-1896
     (replacement stone)
 
CAIN, James A. 1799-1896
     Elner, wife 1802-1896
     Andres, 11/10/1865  age 27 yrs. 
CAMPBELL, Mary Ann wife of Hiram d 1/31/1885 67 y 6m 21ds  
CHRISTMAN, Jacob   b 10.26/1830 - d ?
     HARDENDORF, Ester, wife of Jacob b 10/23/1838 (?) - d ? 
CHRISTMAN, Iantha J., wife of Edgar C., MUNGER b. 3/21/1854 - d 6/21/1895 
CHRISTMAN, daughter of Byron M. and Ida J. Christman d. 3/2/1881 age 1y 2m & 12d 
COLLINS, Maria (Our Mother) wife of Henry TEHERS d. _____1891 
COLLINS (all on same stone)
     Jane S. Collins b. 10/9/1827  d 1/25/1882
     John L. KLING   b. 10/28/1820 d 11/6/1885
     Maria, wife       b. 4/27/1822 d 1/23/1881
     John L. HYNEY d 4/21/1872  age 30 yrs.
     Helena, wife 1843-1928 
COLLINS, John M.  1816-1900 (?)
     Betsey W. 1816-1900(?) 
COLLINS, Charles J. 4/27/1843 - 12/29/1906 age 63 yrs
     Alvena A., wife 11/30/1863  17yrs 26d.
COLLINS, Cornelius  died 12/11/1802 aged 47 yrs
COPP/
NEVILLE, Charles J. 1859-1941
     Eldora(?) G. 1860-1948
     Mary J. Neville  1846-1934
COPP, John 1833-1901
     Maria - wife 1838-1919
     Edger - son 1877-1905
     John H. - son 1857-1860
     This is a newer stone/perhaps a replacement
CHRISTMAN, Martin 10/25/1802 - 4/17/1874
     Sally Saulisbury 1796-1888 
CLEMENT, Gertrude LYKER wife 5/26/1882
     John S. , 5/24/1872
     Elizabeth wife of John GORDON 1832-1/22/1907
     Emma, wife of Peter SMITH 10/21/1862
     (All of the above on same stone) 
DEY, N. Hattie 5/27/1862  23yrs
     James W.  11/3/1863 
DEY, Mary A., wife of Joseph Dey 10/11/1866 57 yrs 3m
 
DEY, David W.  7/20/1862 28yrs 7m 10d 
DEY, Mary Jane wife of C. L. WAGGONER d 5/14/1904
ELMENDORE  J. H. (This was on the base. Actual stone is gone)
FINKLE, Martin L. 1847-1928
FINKELL, Frances 1841-1887
     George 1846-1906
     Joseph J. 2/2/1817 - 4/28/1885
     Mary E. - wife 3/8/1819 - 6/29/1902
FOX, Chauncey W. 1846-1910
     Ada Fox Hill 1853-1936
FRENCH, James W.  9/15/1818 - 1/5/1890
     Catharine J. 2/26/1824-10/10/1896
FRITCHER, Conrad 2/3/1870 83 yrs 1 m 1 d
     Nancy Empie wife 9/10/1860 66yrs 2m 5d
GARDINIER, Abraham M. 1798-1872 (see note 1 below)
     Rhoda GRANTIER - wife 1799-1867
     Louisa H. 1835 - 19___(no date listed)
     Menzo 1839 - 19___
     Celia WOOD his wife 1842-1896
     Gone But Not Forgotten
GEWEYE(?), James M.  5/7/1869  23yrs(?)
GILBERT, Richard 5/30/1869 78yrs
     Mary  - wife 11/20/1870 78 yrs 8 m 15dys
     She left this life of care,
     Received eternal rest
     In answer to her life long prayer
     She with Christs saints is blessed.
     Abigail, daughter of R. & M. Gilbert 10/20/1849 23 yrs 8 m.  Gone to Rest.
GORDON, John 7/21/1917  77 yrs
     Annah E. wife 4/16/1875  30 yrs
     Ostrom - son 5/8/1875 5 yrs 3 d
     Infant Daughter 4/25/1875 - 2 dys
     Floyd H. - son 1/31/1897 9 yrs 5 ds 
GORDON, Henry L. 1848-1926
     Della M. Gordinier 1852-1929, wife
GORDON, Sarah E. wife of John A. Gordon 5/25/1932 87y 4m 7d 
GORDON, Henrietta 6/6/1855 - 8/24/1872
     Orville A. 8/26/1859 - 8/24/1939
     Jacob H. Quick 9/22/1812 - no death date 
GORDON, Menzo 1837-1916
     Mary E. HYNEY, wife 1836-1919
     Lester, son 1866-1906
     Jennie, Daughter 1874-1944
     Eldora CRESS  1908-1961 
GORDON, Alvin I.  2/1/1815 - 8/18/1881
     Catharine - wife 1/14/1817 - 11/15/1900
     Children of Alvin & Catharine Gordon
     David 12/23/1841 - 1/10/1864
     Gilbert 9/16/1852 - 12/16/1877
     Edwin 9/14/1854 - 9/22/1872 
GORDON, Julius C. 1850-1930
     Alvira H. 1848-1937
GRANDY, John N. Member of Co. F. 98th Regt. N.Y.S.V.
     Died October 26, 1864 from wounds received 
     at the capture of Ft. Harrison, VA 9/29/1864
     Aged 21 yrs 7m 26d 
GRANDY, Libbie A. daughter of Herny & Mary Grandy 4/1/1863 1yr 9 m
GRANTIER, Abram L. (no date) Mason
     Elizabeth F. Taylor - wife 5/6/1890 60 yrs 8m 9d 
GRANTIER, Charles W. 12/30/1819 - 9/19/1881
     Margaret 7/24/1821 - 9/29/1890 
GRANTIER, Samuel 1/5/1867 - 73 yrs (?)
     Dorcan(?) wife 5/23/1872 78 yrs.
GRANTIER, Ester Ann wife of Gilbert R. Grantier 9/28/1872 35yr 10m 16d
     Gracie M. dau. of Gilbert & Esther Grantier 5/29/1886  16yrs 9 m
HANSON/
ZIELIE, Nancy Zielie wife of Peter Hanson died at Argusville N.Y. 7/4/1902 aged 74 yrs.
     I have fought a good fight - I have finished my course--I have kept the faith.
     Peter Hanson died at Argusville N.Y. 2/3/1901 aged 79 yrs.
     Willis G. Hanson 1859-1909
HAZZARD/
WALTERS, Clara Walters wife of Chas. H. Hazzard 9/19/1883 - 7/7/1906
HOAG, Infant son of M. and Ann E. Hoag born and died 9/17/1865
HOLLAWAY, William 3/29/1840 25yrs 3m 22 dys 
HOTALING, Jacob 2/16/1882 - 63 yrs
     Anna, wife 11/4/1888 61 yrs
HUESTED, John 4/20/1881 60 yrs
HUNT, Edward 11/8/1871  37 yrs 6 m 21 d 
HUNT, Dewitt J. 8/4/1828 - 10/31/1902 
HUNT, Ophelia 10/1/1888 48 yrs 10m 21 d
HYNEY, Stephen 2/7/1813 -3/4/1896
     Mary - wife 2/21/1817 - 9/14/1896
     Catharine - wife 4/3/1859 aged 44yr 6m 18d 
HYNEY, Menzo, son of S. & C. 2/6/1846 4yrs 3m 6d 
HYNEY, Josiah 6/11/1901  84 yrs 7m 1 d
     Eliza (stone flat & mostly buried)
     Charles Henry son of Josiah and Eliza 10/7/1849 14(?) yrs 16d
     George W., son of Josiah (stone broken off) 
HYNEY, John J. 11/10/1810 - 10/13/1884
     Jane - wife 12/17/1857  44 yr 8 m 17d
     Anna Mariah - wife 1/30/1822 - 1/31/1895
     Sarah 3/26/1862 6m 20d
JOHNSON, James 9/29/1812 - 10/9/1850
     Harriet dau of Joseph & Alice Johnson 12/22/1875
     Danley - son of James & Margaret (no date) 66yrs 1 m 8 d
     Johnson 1/11/1818 2yrs 3m
JOHNSON, Sarah 10/27/1847  32yrs
     Joseph(?) Johnson 10/26/18___
     Alice Johnson, wife(?) of Joseph Johnson departed this life 6/1/1843 73yrs 4m 1(?)d
KILTS/
SOMMER, Conrad 3/6/1890 64 yrs 11m 6d
     Elizabeth H. SOMMER - wife 1826-1913
     John C. Kilts - son 1858-1926
KLING, Elmer son of L. W. & M. Kling 1/24/1875 2m 7d 
KLING, Henry N. 8/18/1830(?) - 6/16/1861
     Mary A. Hyney - wife 1/1/1815 - 10/3/1904(?)
     Children of Henry and Mary Kling
     Mary Jane 6/6/1835 - 12/29/1838
     John Henry 11/30/1837 - 12/26/1838
     Malvina 10/29/1841 - 3/11/1848(?)
     Charles 12/26/1813 - 2/23/1815
LETTIS, Hattie C., daughter of Oscar & Nancy 11/20/1896  20 y 2m
LETTIS, Nancy M., wife of Oscar Lettis 1837-1905
     Hattie C. daughter of Oscar & Nancy M. 11/20/1896 20 y 2 m
LITTLE, Charles W., son of William & Mary 12/19/1864 23 yrs 10m 14d
MALLETT/DAVIS, Ann Maria Davis wife of Dillozon Mallett 4/9/____ 
MALLETT/SECOY, Isabella A. Mallet wife of Andrew Secoy 2/28/186(?)
MCCANN, Almira - adopted daughter of M. & E. McCann 5/13/1875 11yrs
     Gone But Not Forgotten
MINER/MARKLE, Cora B. Markle wife of John Miner 5/4/1868 - 6/4/1916 
MINER/WELLS, Claracya Wells wife of David Miner 8/4/1851 - 12/20/1904
MITCHELL, William 6/31/1881 
MITCHELL, Robert J. 1823-1901
     Christiana PUTMAN, wife 1831-1919 
NEVILLE, John 10/10/1879  68 yrs 2m 18d
     Julia Ann GRANTIER wife 9/12/1872  56yrs 7m 
NEVILLE, Grantier 9/17/1896 - 57 yrs
     Allie G. Gilbert 9/19/1870 25 yrs - wife
     Isabell C. Tayler - 5/5/1869  wife
     Elizabeth M. Hutton 12/4/1887  wife
PHILLIPS,  ___________wife of Peter Phillips died 12/3/1877 (stone broken/pieces missing)
QUACKENBUSH, Conrad  10/21/1860 30 yrs
REYNOLDS, James 3/19/1878 84 yrs 6 m 12 d
     Hannah, wife 9/14/1800 66 yrs 
REYNOLDS, ____les  11/18/1888 25 yrs
     Mary Reynolds __________(?) 
REYNOLDS, George 9/7/1891 65 yrs 11m 7d
     Sarah Ann, wife
     Infant son 3/20/1867
     James L. 9/25/1800 8 yrs 3 m
ROBERTS, Charles E., son of John and M___ Roberts 5/27/1866  8 yrs
SALISBURY, Anna M. - our baby 
SALISBURY, John  - A Member of the Bar 8/21/1870 63 yrs 1 m 7 dys
     Margaret, wife 10/9/1856 46yrs 5m 28ds 
SECOY, Nicholas  6/ - / 1864
     Jacob H. 7/22/1868
SHOEMAKER, Katie 1/12/1882  2y 9m
     Rosie 1/20/1882 4y 2m
SIMMONS, Emma J. wife of A. E. PHILLIPS 1859-1902
SMITH, Jacob W. 2/15/1808 - 1/6/1890
     Catherine, wife 1/8/1819 - 3/3/1893
     Charles - son
SMITH, Eliza E. wife of John H. Smith 8/30/1876  29y 5m 10d
SOMMERS, David 1805-1882
     Sally M.  wife  1809-1884
SWEATMAN, Newton Filmore 3/28/1849 - 2/18/1905
TAYLOR, Luther 7/ _ /1883
     Magdalene, wife 10/_/1870 
TAYLOR, Spencer A. 1826-1837
     Nancy A.  1837-1908
     Libbie M. daughter 4/17/1876(?) 11 yrs 
TEHERS, Charles H. 3/_/1875 - (Mason) 
TEHERS, Henry 3/20/1868  68y 10m 12 d
VINGEHT(?), William H. (stone unreadable)
 
WILLSE, Squire J.  7/6/1882 69yrs 3m 18d 
VAN DUSEN, Anna BOZINA, wife of Aaron 1/6/1871 
VAN DUSEN, Andrew 10/29/1867  18yrs
     Elizabeth Ann wife 2/9/1872
     Ellen Maria, daughter 12/24/1862 18yrs 3m 15 dys.
WINNIE, George L.  5/14/1814 - 8/6/1887
     Hannah A.  5/8/1812 - 4/20/1881
     Mary Adell 9/30/1861 8 yrs 2 ds
     Winnie, son of J.__ Slingerland 9/7/1884 9 yrs & 7 ms
WINTERS, Charles F. 9/15/1872 20y 6m 7d
????????, George, 1/4/18__  68 yrs 7m 28 dys
     Cyrena wife of George ___________

Notes

Note 1:

Baptism Record of the Caughnawaga Reformed Church, Fonda, NY 1758-1899 (now the Reformed Church of Fonda) pg 101:2261 Born 29 May 1798, bp. 1798 (no date).  Abraham, of Martinus Gardineer & Antie Huck.  [no wit.]

contributed by Cliff Lamere


A Note to Researchers using this Web-site: As you use this site, please keep in mind the difference between primary and secondary sources and the importance of building a preponderance of evidence. Accept nothing without further checking. It is our hope that through this collection of data from many sources, you will find a piece of the puzzle that you are working on and that may lead you to further discoveries.

Links to external web sites are being provided as a convenience and for informational purposes only; they do not constitute an endorsement or approval of any of the products, services or opinions contained in any external web site.

Welcome Page of Schoharie County NYGenWeb Site
This page established September 17, 2003