Search billions of records on


Middlebury, NY

formed from the town of Warsaw on 20 March, 1812



Welcome to the Middlebury, NY town web page.  This page is new as of 12 Sep 2009, and is a work in progress.  Comments, corrections, suggestions and submissions are greatly appreciated.  Please submit any information that you have, including family stories, photos, etc.  This is everybodys page, and all Middlebury information is welcome.



You are visitor number  


From Gazetteer of the State of New York by J. H. French, published in 1860:

Middlebury was formed from Warsaw, March 20, 1812.  It lies on the N. border of the co., E. of the center.  Its surface is a rolling upland, broken by the deep valleys of the streams.  Oatka Creek flows through the S.E. corner, and Little Tonawanda Creek through the W. part.  A deep ravine extends E. and W. through near the center of the town, forming a natural pass between the valleys of these two streams.  The hills that border upon Oatka Creek are steep and 400 to 600 ft. high.  The soil is a gravelly and clayey loam.  Wyoming, on Oatka Creek, near the E. border of the town, contains the Middlebury Academy, 3 churches, and 378 inhabitants.  West Middlebury, a station on the B. & N.Y. City R.R., contains 20 dwellings.  The first settlement was made by Jonas Sellick, (from Rutland co., Vt.) in 1802, near Wrights Corners.  There are 5 churches in town.

The earliest settlers of Middlebury, NY named the town after their place of nativity - Middlebury, VT.  History indicates that these first settlers from Middlebury, VT were: Jabez Warren (1802), Amzi Wright (1805), Jonas Sellick, Reuben Chamberlain, Frederick Gilbert, and Israel M. Dewey.  A list of these and other early settlers of Middlebury can be found here.


Some place names in the town of Middlebury:


Census information

When searching for census information on Middlebury, look for the following:



(also see Links)


Vital Records

some early vital records taken from newspapers can be found here


WorldGenWeb Project:

USGenWeb Project:


Wyoming County NY GenWeb:

Rootsweb cemetery search (some Wyoming county cemeteries; please add notes to records to help others in their search):

Rootsweb newspaper search (Batavia newspapers often had mention of births, marriages and deaths in Wyoming county):



This webpage created and maintained by D R Spencer:

This page was last modifiedSunday, 11-Apr-2010 14:24:34 MDT