Guidelines for Analyzing Evidence*
-
Direct evidence is easier to understand, but indirect evidence can carry
equal weight.
-
Reliable genealogical conclusions are based on the weight-not quantity-of
the evidence found.
-
Evidence should be drawn from a variety of independently created sources.
-
Original source material generally is more reliable than derivative material.
-
The reliability of a derivative work is influenced by the degree of processing
it has undergone.
-
The purpose of a record and the motivation of its creators frequently affect
its truthfulness
-
The most reliable informants have firsthand knowledge of the events to
which they testify.
-
The veracity and skill of a record's creator will have shaped its content.
-
Timeliness generally adds to a document's credibility.
-
Penmanship can establish identity, date, and authenticity.
-
A record's custodial history affects its trustworthiness.
-
All known records should be used and a thorough effort made to identify
unknown materials.
-
The case is never closed on a genealogical conclusion.
* Elizabeth Shown Mills, CG, CGL, FASG, FNGS. Evidence!
Citation & Analysis for the Family Historian (Baltimore: Genealogical
Publishing Co., 1997), p. 44