Located in Craig City, Virginia
Photos and notes provided by Stephen A. Taylor
So far I have found at least 6 different names for said cemeteries - Wagener - Caldwell, Confederate, Yoder - Walker, McDonald, Craig City and Carper Cemetery in Craig City. As you leave New Castle going into Craig City - you can take the first right after crossing the bridge and follow (I think the name of the street is Commerce Street) any way follow that street until you get to 4th St. and the cemetery is on the right - it is now enclosed with a very nice split rail fence.
The following people were copied from the web site Find A Grave and are listed as being in two different Cemeteries in Craig County.
McDonald, Col. John C. 14 Mar 1831 23 Dec 191 - CSA 22nd Virginia Infantry Regt. born in Montgomery County, Virginia
Britts, Pvt. George Washington 1831 21 Feb 1866 CSA
McDonald, Annie R. 13 Jan 1859 23 Jul 1923
McDonald, John Walter 28 Feb 1859 20 Feb 1928
Wagner, Pvt. Fleming Bowyer 3 Jan 1845 9 Apr 1936 CSA
Wagner, Pvt. Jacob Carper 21 Dec 1843 9 Apr 1936 CSA
Yoder, Anna W. 3 Sep 1831 26 Jun 1906
Yoder, William Larose 19 Mar 1830 23 Jun 1900
*****------*****------******------*****------*****-----*****-----*****-

Picture of Cemetery taken in the 1930s provided by Claudia Huffman
View of cemetery as you approach from New Castle downtown
Another view of cemetery many thanks go out to Heather Welch and her friends who Cleaned up the area and built the nice fences, as I said many, many thanks Heather.
A view of the area beside the cemeteries
A view of inside the fence to see how clean and neat the area is now
McDonald, J. W. {John Walter} 28 Sep 1859 20 Feb 1928
McDonald, J. W., son of Col. John Claiborne McDonald, died in Hillsboro, Texas, of flu on 20 Feb 1928, age 68; son William, body brought back to New Castle and buried in Carper Cemetery near Parents. Survivors: Widow; two sons; sister, Mrs. Andrew Powhatan Smith Webster Springs, WV; niece, Mrs. T. C. Ragan Christiansburg.
McDonald, Anne R. 13 Jan 1861 23 Jul 1923 {Daughter of John Claiborne & Paulina Platt}
McDonald, J. C. 13 Mar 1831 22 Dec 1914 {Married to Paulina Platt}
McDonald, Col. J. C. {John Claiborne} born 3 Mar 1831 died 22 Dec 1914, just short of 84 years; was CSA, Veteran 22nd Virginia Infantry; buried in McDonald plot in Craig City, with Masonic Rites. Survivors: three daughters; Mrs. Alice Richardson & Miss Annie Craig City; Mrs. Andrew Powhatan Smith (Eliza) Nicholas County, WV; son, John W. Hillsboro, TX. ? (Unmarked grave McDonald, Paulina Platt 5 Jul 1826 15 Oct 1898)
A close up of George Washington Britts stone
Britts, George Washington Co B 28th Virginia Infantry CSA with cross marker
George Washington Britts Military Marker with no dates on it The United States Flag & the Confederate Flag CSA
View of cemetery from George Washington Britts grave
View of fenced area containing the Yoder graves
View from the back of Yoder area
Yoder, William Larose 19 Mar 1830 23 Jun 1900
Yoder, Anna W. 3 Sep 1831 26 Jun 1906
Close up of Anna Yoders dates
Kenney, Edward Thomas 1830 1900 & Kenney, Sarah Humphriss 1840 1927
Yoder, Sara Anna 17 Jul 1896 20 Sep 1898 d/o Howard W. Yoder & Anna W. Thomas Yoder
Close up of Sara Anna Yoder stone
Full view of Sara Anna Yoder stone
Rankin, Ella Ada d/o Thomas A. & Susan L. Rankin Born: 11 Nov 1856 Guilford County, North Carolina Died: 12 Jun 1935 in New Castle, Va. Age 77 7 -1
Rankin, Ella Ada, native of Greensboro, N. C., died in New Castle, at her home of a stroke, On 12 Jun 1935, age 77 years 7 months and 1 day, buried in Carper Cemetery, Craig City. Survivors: two brothers; A. L. & J. I. Rankin; sister; Miss Joynce; and half sister; Mrs. Victor Atkins all of Greensboro half brother Claude Rankin Roanoke.
Another view of Ella Ada Rankin stone
Neilson, Thomas Bonar 6 Jul 1897 age 64 years Of Glasgow, Scotland
Neilson, Thomas Bonar a closer view A closer view of Neilson marker still very hard to read
Walker, Edward Lee 20 Aug 1866 4 Aug 1926 Liberal in good works His generosity to Randolph Macon College has made Possible the education of young men for the ministry. Erected by the Trustees of Randolph Macon College
Walker, Ed Lee; Madison County native, lived in Craig for thirty five years, died on 4 Aug 1926, age 60; buried in Carper Cemetery, New Castle. Survivors: Widow, nee Emilie F. Yoder, daughter of Wm. L. (Married 12 Dec 1900); three Brothers; one sister; Mrs. Walker was helpless invalid several years, and he cared for her; She died in Dec of same year.
Walker, Emilie Yoder 6 Sep 1861 24 Dec 1926
Walker, Emilie Frances (Yoder), widow of Ed Lee Walker, born 6 Sep 1861; d/o Wm. L. Yoder Of Pottsville, Pennsylvania, died at her home on 24 Dec 1926 in New Castle; buried in the Carper Cemetery. Survivors: sister, Mrs. Clara Stine Albany, New York; brother; H. W. Yoder Raleigh.
Another view of cemetery
Huffman, Mary E. {Mary Elizabeth Carper} 11 Nov 1862 13 Jan 1898 Wife of the Hon. Giles G. Huffman
Huffman, Hon. Giles Caldwell 25 Nov 1851 1 Sep 1888
Huffman Stones in fenced area
Abbott, Ollie Carper 26 Feb 1867 21 Nov 1907 {Caroline Olivia Carper, wife of Byrdine Akers Abbott}
Close up of Ollie Carper Abbott stone
Ireland, Richard 25 Aug 1900 20 Feb 1904
Full view of Ireland stone
Thomas, Byrdine 12 Sep 1895 18 Sep 1896
McCartney, Thomas Benton 2 Feb 1839 9 Apr 1912 & C.S.A. {Married on 23 Dec 1869 to Emily Frances Carper} McCartney, Emily F. 16 Sep 1859 19 Mar 1896
Large stone for Thomas Benton McCartney & Wife
Large Stone (?) Carper
Footstone with M. E. H.
Close up of Carper, Martha 10 Dec 1832 19 Mar 1887
Carper, Martha 10 Dec 1832 19 Mar 1887
Full view of Carper, Martha stone
Footstone M. A. C.
Footstone F. R. C.
Footstone E. F. M. (Emily Frances McCartney)
Footstone T. B. M. {Thomas Benton McCartney)
Footstone behind the one for Emily McCartney
Back of Thomas Benton McCartney stone with Iron Cross
McCartney, Robert 9 Sep 1893 1 Jan 1894 Son of T. B. & M. E. McCartney
Carper, Russell B. 21 Mar 1886 4 Jul 1887
Footstone R. B. C. {Corner broke off with C.}
Footstone with L.
Footstone E. C.
Carper, Ola Star 14 Feb 1884 19 Jul 1885 Son of Isaac J. & Amanda Kessler Carper
Possible footstone with nothing on it lying on the ground
Half of headstone base half way buried in the ground
Fenced in Carper Part of the cemetery
Fenced in Yoder Part of cemetery
Standing near the back of cemetery looking toward the road
Wagener, F. B. 3 Jan 1845 16 Sep 1936 & CSA Wagener, Fannie Starks 5 Nov 1853 29 May 1932
I have fought a good fight, I have finished my course, I have kept the faith 2 Tim
Wagener, Fleming Bowyer, died of cancer at home in New Castle, 16 Sep 1937, aged 91 years 8 months and 0 days, born Jan 1846; CSA Veteran in Clarks Batt. Married on 23 Apr 1878 to Fannie L. Starke, decd ; buried in Caper Cemetery.
Wagener, Fannie L. (Starke); wife of Fleming Bowyer (Married 23 Apr 1878; died 29 May 1932, age 79th year; buried Carper Cemetery, Craig City.
Survivors: Husband; three children, Mrs. Ada M. Fox Crewe; Mrs. Zilla Kessler & Mrs. Luther Marion Caldwell New Castle; two sisters.
Wagener, F. B. 30 Bn VA Sharpshooters CSA
Wagener, F. B. (Military marker beside his large marker with flags & Iron Cross
Caldwell, Luther M. June 9, 1872 28 Jan 1949 & Caldwell, Bertha W. (Wagener) 20 Jan 1879 6 Oct 1970 {D/o Fleming Bowyer Wagener & Fannie L. Starke}
Full view of Caldwell Stone
Marker base with marker missing
Standing behind the Wagener Marker looking across cemetery
View of cemetery from behind the Wagener marker
View of Carper Part of Cemetery from middle of cemetery