July 30 that most important affair,
the explosion of the mine under ELLIOTT's Salient occurred. The story of
the mine has often been told, but seldom fairly. Great injustice has been
done General BURNSIDE in the recitals. The gallant corps that made the
fight unaided and alone, losing more than 4000 of its men, deserves better
treatment concerning that affair than historians have accorded it. General
BURNSIDE had fixed upon his plan of assault, his troops had been drilled
with special reference to its execution, and all his arrangements had been
made with that in view. On the evening before the assault he is compelled
by his superior officers to change his plan in entirety and in detail and
sent out to fight single-handed, not his battle, but theirs. It seemed
almost the irony of fate, not only that he should have been sent to make
the fight contrary to his own better judgment, but that his associates,
on the right and left, should have failed to fire even a single gun to
attract the enemy's attention while he withdrew his poor broken, bleeding
corps, when it became evident to spectator and participant that there was
nothing to stay for longer except death. It is some consolation to find
that General GRANT, too great and just to be opinionated, admitted in his
testimony before the committee on the conduct of the war, that he was then
of the opinion that if BURNSIDE had been permitted to carry out his own
plan, the assault would probably have been successful, and that meant the
capture of Petersburg in July, 1864, instead of April, 1865. General MEADE
does not go so far, but he admits that he may have been mistaken. Of the
work of the Seventeenth in that affair little need be said, and no member
of the regiment need blush for the part he played that day. Lieutenant-Colonel
CUMMINGS had been ill for some weeks and unfit for service, and Major REYNOLDS
led the regiment, numbering eight officers and 120 men. All that men could
do they did, but in vain, and when all was over,
"They
that had fought so well
Came
through the jaws of death,
Back
from the mouth of hell,
All
that was left of them." |
The loss of the regiment was ten killed,
forty six wounded, eighteen missing, total seventy-four. Major REYNOLDS,
than whom no braver officer could be found in any regiment, was killed
while encouraging his men to beat back the enemy. Of the other officers
who were with the regiment, Lieutenants MARTIN of company E, HICKS of company
F, BINGHAM of company G and CONVERSE of company H were killed; Captain
KENFIELD of company C and Lieutenant PIERCE of company D were captured,
leaving only one, Lieutenant NEEDHAM of company H, to come back from the
enemy's lines, and he died a week later from wounds received that day.
The fragment of a regiment that remained was divided into two battalions
under First Sergeants JUDSON and LUCIA of companies A and H respectively,
and Adjutant PECK, the only commissioned officer present except the Surgeon,
assumed command, although sick. The regiment numbered hardly more than
100 now present and many of these were under the surgeon’s care. It was
a sorry time. PECK was soon succeeded in command by Captain KNAPP, who
was released from detached service that he might return to his regiment,
and he in a short time by Captain EATON, who was also allowed to return
and soon after promoted to Major.

Lieutenant-Colonel CUMMINGS soon after
went to Vermont because of his health and Major EATON continued in command.
August 13, company I, Capt. Daniel
CONWAY, with 87 men, joined the regiment. Officers and men began to return
to the regiment and September 1 there were 233 present for duty. About
the 18th of August the Fifth Corps, occupying the line next on our left
was moved to the left to take the Weldon railroad, and our corps moved
along to occupy the vacated position. On the 19th POTTER's division, with
two other divisions of the corps, went to the support of the Fifth Corps
that had been attacked. With this aid the Fifth Corps held its position
on the railroad and even gained some ground which was enclosed within the
Union entrenchments. Two days later the enemy made a desperate attempt
to drive the Fifth Corps from its position on the railroad. POTTER's division
took part in the fighting, the regiment was in line, but was not put in
and sustained no loss. For a few days the regiment occupied Fort Sedgwick,
commonly called Fort Hell, just opposite the rebelFort Mahone, which usually
was called Fort Damnation, appropriate names for the two.

During most of September the duties
of the regiment were of a less dangerous nature, strengthening the works
on the line to the left of the Jerusalem Plank Road. Late in the month
it was proposed to force back the enemy's right and swing our left in towards
Petersburg to get possession of certain roads, and perhaps ultimately to
reach the Southside railroad. The junction of the roads aimed at was at
PEEBLES farm five or six miles south and west of Petersburg. An advance
line of Confederate works about a mile in front of this main line guarded
the position. The movement was made by General WARREN with two divisions
of the Fifth Corps and General PARKE with the Second and Third divisions
of the Ninth Corps. Early in the forenoon, WARREN swung his line
around, pushing before it the enemy's skirmishers and his advance line,
which fell back reluctantly but without stubborn contest. The divisions
of the Ninth Corps being in reserve at the right had to march some distance
to reach the position assigned them at the left of the Fifth Corps. Shortly
after noon the Seventeenth, with GRIFFIN's brigade, had passed beyond the
former line of the Fifth, across the field over which that corps had fought
earlier in the day and was well around the left of the Fifth as then deployed,
and facing north. Through someone's fault the brigade was sent much too
far to the left, and after being partly deployed in some woods, was re-called,
moved a mile or more to the right, then to the front passing close by the
PEEBLES house, and along the road at the right of the woods. When the line
was being formed for the advance, Surgeon EDSON requested Lieutenant-Colonel
CUMMINGS to send with him a good man to take
charge of the Stretcher Corps, who would see that they did not lag behind.
Lieutenant LUCIA, who had returned on the 28th from a few days stay in
the hospital at City Point, and was awaiting the arrival of his commission
sent out but recently, volunteered for the duty. It is said that on this
occasion the Stretcher Corps and stretchers kept on the advance line steadily
abreast with the colors, but were not needed. By one of those inexcusable
mysteries, blunders really, so common during the war, a portion of the
Fifth Corps failed to be in place, leaving a wide gap over low woodland
between the right of GRIFFIN's brigade and the left of the Fifth Corps.
Through this gap a large force of the enemy made its way to our rear, and
while the brigade was pressing the enemy in front it was savagely assaulted
in flank and rear, and at the same time in its front. On the discovery
of the force in our rear the order had been given to fall back, but its
execution was another thing, and in doing so many of the brigade were killed,
wounded and captured. It was here that Lieutenant LUCIA, in trying to bring
off his little command, lost his left arm. GRIFFIN's brigade having the
right of the line, with the Seventeenth its right regiment was driven back
in great disorder. The First Brigade shared a similar fate, as also one
brigade of the Third Division. POTTER's whole line was forced back more
than a mile, losing heavily in prisoners.
Near the PEGRAM house a final stand
was made, the broken and disordered fragments of the Ninth Corps were halted,
and with the aid of a division of the Fifth Corps, checked the advance
of the enemy about dark and permanently held the line. [note: this would
be late 29 SEP] The loss of the regiment was eight killed, three of them
officers, forty wounded, two mortally, and twenty-seven missing, nine of
whom died in the hands of the enemy, total seventy-five. Lieutenant-Colonel
CUMMINGS fell gallantly encouraging his men, and his last order was, "Look
out for the colors." Major EATON, conspicuous there as elsewhere for his
coolness, was killed, as was also Lieutenant TOBIN of company I. There
was a woody swamp and stream to be crossed in falling back, and here, with
the confusion into which the troops had already been thrown by the appearance
of the enemy in their rear, they became inextricably mixed. Adjutant PECK
on his way out, made several attempts to rally the scattered men around
the colors. In this he met with some success, and at one point the temporary
line so formed retarded the progress of the advancing enemy long enough
to enable a section of a battery to
withdraw and save its guns. Captain KNAPP, after making his way out of
the swamp and woods with such members of the regiment as he had been able
to collect, found Adjutant PECK with the color-guard and colors and assumed
command, and reported the regiment as on duty near the PEEBLES house, where
it remained that night, [now 30th of SEP] and the next morning was ordered
to a position in the new line which had been formed a half mile to the
rear and near the PEGRAM house. A day or two later Adjutant PECK, with
Captain CONWAY and Lieutenant NORTON, were sent to the hospital, and Captain
KNAPP for nearly a month commanded the regiment, having at first but 84
men, Surgeon EDSON being the only other commissioned officer present for
duty. October 27, company K, Captain YALE, with 95 men and Colonel RANDALL
joined the regiment. The losses of the regiment in killed and wounded up
to this time exceeded by nearly one-third the number it took into its first
fight.

October 27 the regiment participated
in the movement made by the Second, Fifth and Ninth Corps on the enemy's
works at Hatcher’s Run. The burden of the fighting fell to the Second and
Fifth Corps, and the regiment sustained no loss. The next day it returned
to its position on the line. Sometime in November the corps was moved to
the extreme right with its line extending from the river to the left as
far as Jerusalem Plank Road. GRIFFIN's brigade had the left of this line,
and Colonel RANDALL was placed in command of Fort Davis situated on the
brigade's line, with his, the Thirty-first Maine and Fifty-sixth Massachusetts
regiments and two batteries, and there all remained until February 11,
1865, when the regiment was moved about a mile to the left where it occupied
a position on the advance line until the final breaking up in April. During
the winter the regiment took part in frequent skirmishes between pickets,
varied with occasional artillery duels between Fort Davis and its neighbors
across the field, and lost several men, but was in no pitched battle. In
November, Seth W. LANGDON was appointed Assistant
Surgeon in place of Dr. SPOHN, resigned. February 27, 1865, Surgeon EDSON
resigned and took with him the love and respect of every man in the regiment.
|